Open the Control Room

Redraft Team Focus: Dolphins

I’m analyzing every one of the 32 NFL teams and all of their redraft-relevant fantasy assets in this article series. It’s a long project, but I want to make sure that you, the reader, have something you can refer to for every team. For each article, I’ll split up the fantasy assets into three categories: high-end assets, usable contributors, and dart throws. I’ll reference my PPR redraft rankings at the time of writing. If you want to read my previous work in this series, the full list with links is at the bottom of the article. Let’s jump into the Dolphins.

High-End Assets

Given that the Dolphins don’t have a star running back or a high-profile receiver or a strong tight end, it’s no surprise they don’t have a high-end asset. Their offense will have either journeyman Ryan Fitzpatrick or rookie Tua Tagovailoa at quarterback, neither of whom inspire immediate confidence in a redraft format. Let’s move on to the next section.

Usable Contributors

DeVante Parker

After years of failure, DeVante Parker finally broke out in 2019. Here’s a quick look at Parker’s career.

 Year  Games   Targets   Receptions   Yards   TDs   Fantasy Finish   Fantasy PPG 
 2015   14  50  26  494  3  WR78  6.7
 2016  15  87  56  744  4  WR50  10.3
 2017  13  96  57  670  1  WR50  10.0
 2018  11  47  24  309  1  WR105  5.5
 2019  16  128  72  1,202  9  WR11  15.4

The Dolphins drafted Parker in the first round of the 2015 NFL Draft, expecting him to become their top outside receiver to pair with their slot weapon Jarvis Landry. However, from 2015-2018, Parker didn’t live up to the hype. 

After a quiet rookie year Parker spent mostly on the bench, the Dolphins brought in fantasy nightmare Adam Gase as their new head coach for 2016. As fantasy owners know, Gase is the death of all fantasy options and runs a boring offense. In 2016 and 2017, Gase insisted on funneling targets to Landry, whether or not the game plan called for it. Even so, Parker wasn’t as bad as most remember, sharing outside looks with Kenny Stills for those two seasons. Parker flashed his talent for the real-life Dolphins even if he didn’t make an impact in fantasy.

Unfortunately for Parker, the bottom fell out in 2018. Gase decided to put Parker in his doghouse, a death sentence on a Gase-led team. Other players Gase has put there include Ryan Tannehill and Kenyan Drake, so we can’t trust Gase’s judgment of player talent. Throughout 2018, most assumed the Dolphins would trade Parker, but they couldn’t find a deal for him at the trade deadline. The team finished 7-9 that season, and they decided to clean house, firing their whole coaching staff.

Before 2019, the Dolphins started tanking under new head coach Brian Flores, moving on from many veteran players, including Stills. Flores decided that Parker still showed promise, keeping him on the team and handing him a starting role. Parker finally flourished as the Dolphins’ top target in 2019, and he led the team in all receiving categories, despite the emergence of undrafted rookie receiver Preston Williams and second-year tight end Mike Gesicki. In December, the Dolphins rewarded Parker with a contract extension that included $21.5 million in guaranteed money.

Going into 2020, Parker is once again the top receiver on the Dolphins, alongside Williams and Gesicki. However, for fantasy football, Parker is an enigma. In 2019, Parker was only WR36 through Week 9, averaging 11.5 PPR points per game. While that was better than anything he’d done in his career, it was nothing special. After Williams went down to a torn ACL, Parker averaged 19.3 PPR points per game, behind only Davante Adams and Michael Thomas among wide receivers.

I feel like the right move is to split the difference between Parker’s two half-seasons in my 2020 rankings. Parker comes in as my WR21, just behind Courtland Sutton and ahead of Stefon Diggs. The Dolphins have uncertainty at quarterback, and while I love Tagovailoa’s talent, I don’t want a rookie quarterback for my fantasy receiver. Parker is one of the riskiest and most volatile assets this year, so keep that in mind when drafting him.

Jordan Howard

The Dolphins have two fantasy-relevant backs: Jordan Howard and his teammate Matt Breida. I believe that Howard will lead a timeshare in 2020, so he comes in first of the two players. After four seasons in Chicago and Philadelphia, Howard signed with the Dolphins in free agency to a 2-year, $9.75 million contract with $4.75 million guaranteed.

In his career, Howard has excelled as a two-down grinder. From 2016-2018, Howard had 250 or more carries each year, although his efficiency declined over time from 5.2 YPC in 2016 to 3.7 in 2018. Howard also finished as the RB10 in 2016, RB14 in 2017, and RB20 in 2018, while playing 47 of 48 games as a member of the Bears. He was a dull but reliable fantasy asset during those three years.

After 2018, the Bears traded Howard to the Eagles, where he formed a committee with Miles Sanders. From Weeks 1-9, Howard led the backfield, averaging 12.4 PPR points per game, 27th among running backs in that period. He got injured and missed most of the rest of the season, but it’s impossible to deny that Howard was relevant while he was healthy.

Going into 2020, Howard should once again have the chance to lead a backfield, although alongside a far less talented back than Sanders in Breida. While the Dolphins aren’t even half the offense the Eagles were in 2019, I still can’t ignore Howard’s potential workload. Even in a PPR format, Howard is my RB33. I think he’s tremendously undervalued, and I expect to see him on many of my rosters as an RB3 or RB4 this season.

Matt Breida

Some think that Breida will overtake Howard and lead the Dolphins in fantasy production, but I don’t believe it. While the Dolphins signed Howard in free agency, they traded a fifth-round pick to the 49ers to acquire Breida, a lesser investment. As I mentioned in that piece, there’s a perception in the fantasy community that Breida has a massive passing-game upside that will complement Howard. 

Considering that Breida has never had more than 27 receptions in any season, that perspective holds no water. The Dolphins have a pass-catching back in Patrick Laird, who averaged three receptions per game in 2019. While Laird is not fantasy-relevant, he is yet another reason to ignore Breida in drafts. Howard is a superior, more durable option on the ground, and Laird is better in the passing game. Breida is a hard fade for me at my RB47. He’s only in the usable contributors’ section because running backs are so hard to find.

Mike Gesicki

In 2019, Gesicki somewhat delivered on the promise he showed coming into the NFL as a rookie. Like Parker, I believe that Gase misused Gesicki in 2018 and that he didn’t get a fair shot to produce either for the Dolphins or fantasy football. As a second-year player, Gesicki caught 51 of 89 targets for 570 receptions and five touchdowns, finishing as the TE12.

Also, Gesicki’s production spiked after Preston Williams’ injury, just like Parker’s did. In Weeks 1-9, Gesicki averaged 5.7 PPR points per game while in Weeks 10-17, he averaged 11.3. Gesicki’s pace over the second half of the season would have been 60 receptions on 116 targets for 644 yards and 10 touchdowns. 

Unfortunately for Gesicki, Williams is back in the offense for 2020. Even though Gesicki could take a further step forward as a tight end in Year 3, I can’t project him to get 116 targets or to score 10 touchdowns like he paced down the stretch of 2019. Therefore, I rank Gesicki as my TE14. I think it’s a fair price for Gesicki, considering his high upside and low floor.

Dart Throws

Preston Williams

The Dolphins acquired Williams as an undrafted free agent after the 2019 NFL Draft. While I won’t get into specifics here, it’s important to note that Williams fell out of the draft process because of off-field issues, not due to a lack of talent. Therefore, he had more ability coming into the NFL than his draft capital would otherwise imply.

As a rookie, Williams almost immediately became a starter as an outside receiver alongside Parker. In Weeks 1-9, Williams had nearly identical stats to Parker. Williams averaged 11.4 PPR points per game, similar to Parker’s 11.5 average during that period. Williams caught 32 of 60 targets for 428 yards and three touchdowns, outpacing Parker in receptions, targets, and yards.

While Williams had a great run, he did suffer a devastating ACL tear in Week 9. The Dolphins didn’t acquire any significant receiving weapons to complement Parker, Williams, and Gesicki, which shows confidence in Williams’ recovery process. Even with that confidence, I still can’t be sure that Williams will be 100% ready for Week 1. Also, Williams was only the WR37 while he played, so it’s not like he comes with a massive upside. Therefore, Williams is my WR52, due to both high-risk and a low floor. I doubt I’ll draft him anywhere in 2020 as there are just other dart throws at wide receiver that I prefer. 

 Ryan Fitzpatrick and Tua Tagovailoa

While I don’t hate all their offensive weapons discussed previously, I have no interest in the Dolphins’ quarterback situation. Fitzpatrick was surprisingly fantasy-relevant in 2019, finishing as the QB17 with an average of 16.0 fantasy PPG. However, that success occurred mostly because the Dolphins’ defense was historically awful. I don’t expect that to happen again in 2020, as the Dolphins signed multiple free agents on that side of the ball, including star cornerback Byron Jones.

Also, the Dolphins start the season at the Patriots and then against the Bills, two horrible matchups. Avoid this quarterback situation in 1QB leagues, where Fitzpatrick comes in as my QB31. Even in superflex formats, I still don’t want to invest here. We have no idea if and when Tagovailoa will take over the starting job, and that uncertainty is too much for me. Find a quarterback somewhere else, anywhere else.   

Other Options

The Dolphins don’t have any serious alternative options. They have a bunch of low-upside depth receivers: Albert Wilson, Isaiah Ford, Jakeem Grant, and Allen Hurns, none of whom are worth a look in fantasy. This offense isn’t exciting, so I certainly don’t want the fourth receiving option on the team. They also have some backup running backs, most notably Patrick Laird. While Laird might see a few receptions, he’s a waste of time for fantasy owners. Laird won’t see any carries with Howard and Breida in front of him. Stick to the players mentioned earlier if you have to draft someone from this roster.

Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Karp. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.

Previous Redraft Team Focus Articles: Giants, Cardinals, Titans, Bills, Saints, Steelers, Vikings, Chiefs, Cowboys, 49ers, Texans, Jets, Panthers, Browns, Packers, Broncos, Redskins, Rams, Jaguars, Patriots, Falcons, Ravens, Lions, Raiders, Eagles, Seahawks, Colts

Save to list