In this article series, I’m analyzing every one of the 32 NFL teams and all of their redraft-relevant fantasy assets. It’s a long project, but I want to make sure that you, the reader, have something you can refer to for every team. For each article, I’ll split up the fantasy assets into three categories: high-end assets, usable contributors, and dart throws. I’ll reference my PPR redraft rankings at the time of writing, which are here. If you want to read my previous work in this series, the full list with links is at the bottom of the article. Let’s jump into the Browns.
High-End Assets
A couple of months ago, I broke down the Browns’ offseason moves, which you can read about here. To summarize, they signed Austin Hooper to a 4-year, $42 million contract, retained running back Kareem Hunt on a second-round tender, and signed star right tackle Jack Conklin to a 3-year, $42 million deal. Then, in the draft, they added left tackle Jedrick Wills Jr. in the first round.
Nick Chubb
The exciting part of the Browns’ offseason is the effect on Chubb. Everyone is focusing on the fact that the Browns retained Hunt, who will continue to eat into Chubb’s carry and receiving share. While I believe that’s true, let’s not forget that even in the eight games Hunt played, Chubb still had a 1,382-rushing yard seasonal pace. Also, Hooper is an improvement over the previous starter David Njoku as a blocker, and Conklin and Wills should vastly lift the Browns’ offensive line. Even though Hooper is just average in the blocking game, Njoku is one of the worst blockers in the league. Additionally, PFF rated the Browns’ offensive line as the 23rd-best unit in 2019, so they have lots of room to grow in 2020.
I see Chubb as very similar to Derrick Henry. Chubb had 298 carries in 2018 compared to Henry’s 303, so they were close in carry count. The significant differences were that Chubb had 36 receptions while Henry had only 18, but Henry scored 18 total touchdowns to Chubb’s eight. I think the Browns’ offense will be better overall than the Titans’, so Chubb should improve his touchdown total in 2020. While I do expect Chubb to lose a lot of receiving production, I think he could have around 25 catches in 2019, which isn’t bad. Also, the Browns replaced horrific head coach Freddie Kitchens with Kevin Stefanski, who ran the Vikings’ run-heavy attack behind Dalvin Cook in 2019.
Therefore, I think the fantasy industry is way too low on Chubb in 2020. Even in PPR formats, I rank Chubb as my RB7, just behind Henry at RB6. Chubb is my 11th overall player, and I would be happy with him as my stud running back. I expect that if I draft at or near the turn, I’ll start a lot of my teams with a combination of Chubb and a star receiver or Kelce. Don’t make the mistake of fading Chubb in 2020.
Odell Beckham
I think it’s impossible to deny that Beckham was a disappointment in 2019, finishing as the WR25. He failed to develop chemistry with quarterback Baker Mayfield and struggled through a sports hernia injury all season. It was the third straight season where Beckham didn’t indeed pay off on his high draft price. In 2017, he missed the final 12 games after breaking his ankle. Then, in 2018, he played at a stud level for 12 games, averaging 19.2 fantasy points per game, but he missed the fantasy playoffs with a somewhat mysterious quad injury. Therefore, I understand that fantasy players are slightly burnt out on Beckham since he hasn’t put together a full season as a fantasy stud since 2016.
Even with all of those struggles, Beckham is still only 27 years old and enters a second season with Mayfield in 2020. The Browns’ entire team was a disaster in 2019 with Kitchens as head coach. Hopefully, Stefanski can improve the team. While Stefanski is known for running a run-heavy scheme, he keyed in on two star receivers in Adam Thielen and Stefon Diggs, similar to what the Browns have in Beckham and Jarvis Landry.
However, it’s fair to recognize that Beckham comes with added risk in 2020. He’s no longer a consideration anywhere near the first round, and he’s not in my top few tiers of wide receivers. Also, I’d instead take a shot on some running backs that come with question marks in the second round over Beckham. With that said, I do believe that Beckham is the last receiver in my rankings that has a real shot to be the #1 overall receiver, so that keeps him from falling too far. He’s my WR8 and 24th player overall. Given what I’ve seen in drafts, I expect to have a lot of Beckham shares in 2020, since he usually falls further than that.
Usable Contributors
Jarvis Landry
Landry significantly outperformed Beckham in 2019, finishing as the WR12 compared to Beckham’s WR25 finish. He had more targets, yards, receptions, and receiving touchdowns than Beckham, so he was better across the board. However, I’m not expecting a WR1 season from Landry or anything close to that in 2020.
Outside of Beckham and Landry, no Browns’ player had more than 49 targets in 2019. That will change with Hooper on the team, who will compete with Landry for those over-the-middle targets. While both Beckham and Landry are returning from injuries, Landry’s injury is more serious. Landry received hip surgery in February, which will require a minimum 6-month recovery time. Therefore, he should be ready for Week 1, but he will likely miss most of the offseason program.
Based on my expectations for Beckham, Hooper’s addition to the team, and Landry’s injury recovery, I’m currently relatively negative about Landry’s 2020 outlook. I have him ranked as my WR31, although he’s right at the end of a large tier of receivers. I don’t see much of a difference between Landry at WR31 and T.Y. Hilton at WR24. Landry comes in as my 63rd overall player. He could be my WR3 on a team where I drafted three early running backs or even my WR2 if I took a tight end early. I don’t dislike Landry, but I expect to take other receivers in his tier over him.
Kareem Hunt
After serving his eight-game suspension in 2019, Hunt was a decent PPR asset down the stretch. He averaged 12.7 PPR points per game, 23rd among running backs, and just 0.3 points fewer than Chubb. In those eight games, he totaled 43 carries for 179 yards and two touchdowns and added 37 receptions on 44 targets for 285 yards and a touchdown.
Going into 2020, I expect Hunt to play a similar role complementing Chubb. While Hooper could steal a few of Hunt’s targets, I think the Browns’ offense could continue to experiment with using Chubb and Hunt simultaneously. The Browns don’t have a real WR3, so Hunt could also get snaps in the slot, something that the Browns’ coaching staff has stated they will explore in the offseason.
While Hunt has little high-end upside without a Chubb injury, he’s still the best of the pure PPR backs and simultaneously the best handcuff in fantasy football. He’d immediately be a high-end RB1 if Chubb went down. Therefore, Hunt is my RB28, and someone I expect to have shares of in 2020. He’s a great combined floor-ceiling play.
Austin Hooper
I think that Hooper is an excellent all-around tight end. I believe that the Browns primarily signed him to improve their running game, as Njoku is a poor blocker. However, Hooper is also a superior receiver to Njoku. Before Hooper suffered his 2019 injury, he was the TE1 through nine games, averaging 17.2 PPR points per game. In those contests, he had 56 receptions on 67 targets for 608 yards and six touchdowns.
While he didn’t find the same success in 2019 post-injury, Hooper has a proven track record of success. He also finished as the TE6 in 2018, so he’s far from a one-year wonder. He’s played 59 of a possible 64 games in his career, making his 2019 injury less of a concern.
Overall, I love the signing for the Browns in real-life for their offense. Stefanski loves to use tight ends, playing 12 personnel with two receiving tight ends on the field. Hooper and Njoku compare similarly and favorably to Kyle Rudolph and Irv Smith Jr., who were Stefanski’s tight ends in Minnesota.
Unfortunately for Hooper, I don’t think he’s going to be the same fantasy asset in Cleveland that he was in Atlanta. The Browns have two great receivers in Beckham and Landry, just like the Falcons had Julio Jones and Calvin Ridley. However, unlike the Falcons, the Browns have a stellar receiving back in Hunt and another decent receiving tight end in Njoku. Also, Landry is a short-range target, who will directly compete with Hooper for targets.
I don’t think the Browns can support five fantasy assets, and I believe that Hooper is the one who massively underperforms. He’s still my TE10, but he’s unlikely to be on many of my redraft rosters. I want to grab one of the top four tight ends this season: Kelce, Kittle, Ertz, or Andrews. Failing that, I’ll likely pass on the middle group of tight ends and try to grab two late dart throws with my final couple selections. Since Hooper carries name value, he’ll go too early for my taste.
Baker Mayfield
Despite all the Browns’ weapons, I’m not particularly interested in Mayfield as a fantasy quarterback. In 2019, he finished as the QB19 and averaged a paltry 15.6 fantasy points per game. He completed only 59.4% of his passes and threw 22 touchdowns compared to 21 interceptions. He majorly regressed from 2018, where he averaged 17.1 points per game and finished as the QB16, despite only playing 14 games.
Mayfield also adds little on the ground, averaging 136 rushing yards in his two seasons, although he did score three rushing touchdowns in 2019. Therefore, I don’t believe he has a significant fantasy upside. Mayfield is my QB15 for redraft formats. When considering that he opens the season against the Ravens’ tough defense, I certainly won’t draft Mayfield in 2020.
Dart Throws
The Browns don’t have any dart throws worth considering in drafts. Njoku is still on the roster and should have a receiving role. However, he’ll just siphon from Hooper and won’t be fantasy relevant himself. The Browns also drafted Harrison Bryant in the fourth round and Donovan Peoples-Jones in the sixth round. I imagine they’ll both be buried on the depth chart. They both represent interesting dynasty stashes but not redraft plays.
Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Karp. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.
Previous Redraft Team Focus Articles: Giants, Cardinals, Titans, Bills, Saints, Steelers, Vikings, Chiefs, Cowboys, 49ers, Texans, Jets, Panthers
