In a dynasty story, I’ll look at a single player and how his value has fluctuated over time, starting from their college profile. I’ll factor in his NFL stats and generally discuss what he did in each of his NFL seasons. Then, I’ll look at his 2020 prospects before wrapping it up with a final recommendation and dynasty strategy.
Today, it’s time for a deep dive into Devin Singletary. Let’s jump right in!
College Production and NFL Draft Profile
Singletary played three years at Florida Atlantic University in Conference USA. Even though Singletary competed outside a Power 5 school, he still impressed throughout his college career. After splitting touches as a freshman in 2016, Singletary had 301 and 261 carries in 2017 and 2018.
Singletary’s 2017 season was his most impressive, as he turned those 301 carries into 1,918 yards and 32 touchdowns. While he still played well in 2018, he only had 1,348 yards and 22 touchdowns, declining from 6.4 to 5.2 YPC and scoring 10 fewer touchdowns. Also, Singletary’s receptions went down every season from 26 in 2016 to 19 in 2017 to only six in 2018.
Therefore, NFL teams had some questions surrounding Singletary entering the NFL Draft process. Singletary’s stock dropped significantly when he ran a slow 4.66-second 40-yard dash. After that poor time, he fell to the third round, where the Bills selected him with the 74th overall pick.
After the NFL Draft, Singletary was a consensus second-round dynasty rookie pick. He found himself in the second tier of rookie running backs, alongside Darrell Henderson, Damien Harris, and Justice Hill. I thought he was a fair value in that range, although I struggled to see Singletary’s path to 2019 relevance. The Bills had starter LeSean McCoy and free-agent signings in veteran Frank Gore and third-down back T.J. Yeldon, presenting a crowded depth chart for Singletary to climb.
NFL Stat Totals
Here are Singletary’s full NFL stats.
| Year | Games | Carries | Rushing Yards | YPC | Rushing TDs | Fantasy Rank | Fantasy PPG | PPG Rank |
| 2019 | 12 | 151 | 775 | 5.1 | 2 | RB32 | 12.3 | 26th |
Dynasty Value History
Throughout the offseason, Singletary’s value remained relatively stable. Even though he impressed throughout the Bills’ training camp, his path to touches just wasn’t there. However, that all changed when the Bills released McCoy during final roster cuts. Singletary didn’t immediately become the starter, but he now had a clear path to relevance and a far easier road to claim the starting job. For those reasons, Singletary’s value soared, moving into dynasty RB3 territory.
In Weeks 1-2, Singletary played behind Gore, although he managed to unseat Yeldon as the secondary back. However, he suffered a hamstring injury in Week that forced him to miss the next three games. The Bills eased him back into the lineup in Weeks 7-8, before Singletary took over as the workhorse back in Week 9.
From Week 9 forward, Singletary averaged 16.4 carries and 75.4 yards per game, and he excelled as a fantasy and real-life running back. His dynasty value continued to increase, eventually moving into the top-50 overall assets. Singletary was a clear dynasty RB2 from that moment on. He maintained that value throughout most of the 2020 offseason, especially as the Bills let Gore go in free agency.
However, everything changed once the Bills drafted Zack Moss in the third round of the 2020 NFL Draft. The team expressly declared that Moss would play Gore’s old role as the goal-line back. Also, Moss brings a receiving skill set to the table to challenge Singletary for receiving work. As receiving work and goal-line touches are the most valuable fantasy opportunities, Moss represents a real threat to Singletary’s fantasy value.
Over time, Singletary’s value began to slide, as fantasy owners started to realize that Moss would be a factor in 2020. I believe that the dynasty community made a mistake during the early part of the 2020 offseason, valuing Singletary like he could carry a workhorse role. However, Singletary isn’t a workhorse back, and he only acted like one down the stretch in 2019 because the Bills had no other options. After they selected Moss, they don’t intend to deploy Singletary that way again in 2020.
2020 Outlook
I’ve started to worry about Singletary’s 2020 prospects. In a recent risers and fallers article, I had Singletary as a faller. Since then, the Bills have reported that Singletary is having fumbling problems, and he seems to be losing his starting job to Zack Moss. Moss already will play Gore’s old 2019 role, but he could easily take more work from Singletary if he outperforms him.
I still project Singletary as the starter, but it’s far closer than it used to be. Now, I rank Singletary down at RB30 and 71st overall while Moss comes in at RB37 and 90th overall. I don’t expect Singletary to be a workhorse or anywhere near it, and he’s a hard fade at his cost in my 2020 drafts.
Dynasty Recommendation
I think some dynasty owners continue to believe that Singletary will be a workhorse back in 2020. Therefore, I recommend selling Singletary before the season begins, when it will become impossible to deny that Moss has a significant role in the Bills’ rushing attack. I would accept any 2021 first-round pick in exchange for Singletary, but I’d even take less if necessary.
The best move might be to pivot to the wide receiver position. Jarvis Landry, DeVante Parker, and Christian Kirk are all in Singletary’s value range, and I would prefer each of them long-term over Singletary. I don’t believe Singletary even has a high-end RB2 upside. Low-upside but serviceable running backs are the most overvalued players in dynasty leagues, exactly where Singletary falls. I want no part of him going forward.
Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Karp. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.
Previous Dynasty Story Articles: Mike Williams, Kenyan Drake, Dede Westbrook, Mike Evans, Dante Pettis, James Washington