In a dynasty story, I’ll look at a single player and how his value has fluctuated over time, starting from their college profile. I’ll factor in his NFL stats and generally discuss what he did in each of his NFL seasons. Then, I’ll look at his 2020 prospects before wrapping it up with a final recommendation and dynasty strategy.
Today, it’s time for a deep dive into James Washington. Let’s jump right in!
College Production and NFL Draft Profile
Washington had a four-year career at Oklahoma State. He didn’t do much as a freshman in 2014, but he rattled off three straight 1,000-plus yard seasons from 2015-2017. Washington improved in yards and receptions, and he scored double-digit touchdowns in each season.
In 2017, Washington was a consensus All-American and won the Biletnikoff Award for the top college receiver. In dynasty circles, some thought that Washington was a contender for the best receiver in the 2018 draft class, alongside players like Courtland Sutton, Calvin Ridley, and D.J. Moore. Unfortunately, Washington fell in the draft to the 60th overall pick, where the Steelers selected him.
Washington went behind Sutton, Ridley, and Moore, as well as Dante Pettis, Christian Kirk, and Anthony Miller. Because of his slide, Washington fell clearly behind Sutton, Ridley, and Moore, and settled in behind Kirk in the next tier of rookies with Miller and Michael Gallup. Dynasty owners weren’t thrilled with his landing spot, either, as the Steelers had Antonio Brown and JuJu Smith-Schuster entrenched atop their depth chart.
NFL Stat Totals
Here are Washington’s full NFL stats.
| Year | Games | Targets | Receptions | Yards | TDs | Fantasy Finish | Fantasy PPG | PPG Rank |
| 2018 | 14 | 38 | 16 | 217 | 1 | WR124 | 3.1 | N/A |
| 2019 | 15 | 80 | 44 | 735 | 3 | WR55 | 8.9 | 62nd |
Dynasty Value History
Because of his landing spot, Washington’s value fell throughout the summer of 2018. Tight end Vance McDonald emerged as the third target behind Brown and Smith-Schuster, further reducing Washington’s opportunity. Washington also had to compete with Ryan Switzer for the third receiver spot. In 2018, Switzer out-targeted Washington. So, those fears ended up being justified.
Washington’s snaps and role fluctuated somewhat throughout 2018, but he never established himself in the lineup. In Week 15, he had his best game with three receptions for 65 yards, far from a strong performance. As a rookie, Washington caught a miserable 42.1% of his targets and averaged a horrid 5.7 yards/target. Considering that Ben Roethlisberger threw for over 5,000 yards and both Smith-Schuster and Brown finished as WR1s, Washington’s Year 1 performance looked extra bad in comparison.
Because of his poor rookie year, Washington’s dynasty value tanked until the Steelers had a massive shakeup at the wide receiver position. In March 2019, they traded Antonio Brown to the Raiders, opening up a massive 168 target void from 2018. After Brown left, the Steelers replaced him by signing Donte Moncrief in free agency and drafting Diontae Johnson in the third round of the 2019 NFL Draft.
Throughout the 2019 offseason, dynasty owners debated between Washington, Johnson, and Moncrief for who would emerge as the Steelers’ WR2 behind Smith-Schuster. Crazily enough, looking back, most dynasty owners had Washington as the favorite, followed by Moncrief, and then Johnson. As we know now, Moncrief completely flopped in Pittsburgh, and the Steelers released him after a few games.
Washington and Johnson both received the opportunity to play after Moncrief failed. After two games, Roethlisberger went down with an injury, and the Steelers replaced him with Washington’s old college teammate Mason Rudolph. Despite their chemistry, Rudolph preferred Johnson as his top target, especially with Smith-Schuster struggling with injuries.
For the 2019 season, Johnson led the team in targets, receptions, and receiving touchdowns, although Washington edged him out in yards. Washington improved his catch rate to 55.0% and his yards/target to 9.2, a massive boost to his 2018 rookie year. However, Johnson received most of the dynasty attention due to his superior reception numbers, while Washington became profiled as solely a deep threat. Even though Washington significantly improved in Year 2, his dynasty value plummeted as he failed to live up to his college profile.
Then, Washington’s value took a massive hit when the Steelers drafted Chase Claypool with the 49th overall pick in the 2020 NFL Draft. Claypool has the superior draft capital to either Johnson or Washington, and the Steelers declared Claypool was an outside receiver, not a tight end as some believed. Smith-Schuster should slide back into the slot, where he excelled in 2018, leaving two outside receiver spots for Johnson, Washington, and Claypool.
That uncertainty has destroyed Washington’s dynasty value, putting him in a speculative range for most dynasty owners. I have Claypool ranked above Washington at this point, mostly due to Claypool’s draft capital and size. However, I recognize that Washington plays a deep threat role in the Steelers’ offense that no other receiver can offer. Therefore, I haven’t completely lost hope for Washington.
2020 Outlook
Unfortunately, I don’t expect much from Washington in 2020. I believe that Smith-Schuster and Johnson are the Steelers’ top two receivers, and Claypool will challenge Washington for the third receiver spot. Johnson has struggled with a few injuries in camp, and Claypool is a rookie, so I barely have Washington in draftable range at WR76. You could do worse as a late-round flier, but that’s all Washington is.
Dynasty Recommendation
At this point, Washington represents a “hold and pray” dynasty asset. He doesn’t have a good reputation despite showing significant improvement from Year 1 to Year 2. I don’t think he carries much trade value, especially with Johnson and Claypool on the roster. However, Washington could undoubtedly have a Year 3 breakout, like many receivers before him. Roethlisberger looks healthy in camp, so there’s room for multiple Steelers to succeed. Either way, his upside is far more than his value, so hang onto Washington for now.
Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Karp. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.