Open the Control Room

Dead to Me: Jared Cook

My “Dead to Me” shovel is finally back. In one of my favorite series, I figuratively bury a new player in each article. Typically, I expect that player to stay buried after the 2020 season, and the player I’m discussing had significant fantasy value in the past. In this case, it’s time to discuss Jared Cook and his lengthy career. By the time you finish reading, you’re going to trust me, and my take that drafting Cook will demolish your team in 2020 redraft leagues.

2009-2012: Cook’s Career Beginnings

Wow, it seems like Cook has been in the NFL forever. The Titans drafted Cook in the third round of the 2009 NFL Draft. At first, Cook served in a depth role behind veteran tight ends Bo Scaife and Alge Crumpler. Cook only caught nine passes as a rookie and was the third tight end on the Titans. After 2009, Crumpler signed with the Patriots, allowing Cook to move up to the backup role behind Scaife. In 2010, Cook caught 29 of 45 targets for 361 yards and a touchdown and produced similarly to Scaife. While Cook had put up some stats, he had yet to be fantasy-relevant or even get onto fantasy radars.

However, before 2011, the Titans let Scaife leave in free agency, promoting Cook to the top receiving tight end. Cook had a breakout season, finishing third on the team with 81 targets that he converted into 49 receptions for 759 yards and three touchdowns. Despite increased production, Cook only finished as the TE15 and 16th among tight ends with 8.9 fantasy PPG. Then, Cook had a similar season in 2012. He missed three games, giving him lower total stats, but he averaged 9.3 fantasy PPG.

2013-2015: The Middle Years

While Cook’s time in Tennessee was a success, his contract had expired after the 2012 season. He made an unusual demand to be franchise-tagged at the higher-value wide receiver position. The Titans decided not to do that and moved on from Cook. Cook then signed a five-year, $35.1 million contract with the Rams that included $16 million in guaranteed money. The Rams had recently hired Jeff Fisher as their head coach, who was Cook’s original coach in Tennessee.

Even though Cook had gotten a massive free-agent contract, he remained on the borderline of a breakout. He caught 51 of 85 targets for 671 yards and five touchdowns. While Cook led the team in targets, he only managed 9.3 fantasy PPG and finished as the TE12. Through this point in Cook’s career, he had been consistently mediocre. He’d caught around 60% of targets in four of his five seasons and always hovered around the edge of TE1 territory. Cook was nothing special, and most expected him to never quite make that leap to fantasy stardom.

In 2014, Cook’s career took a different turn. He set a career-high with 99 targets, but he only caught 52 of them for 634 yards and three touchdowns. His catch rate declined to a terrible 52.5%, and he dropped down to TE17. Cook averaged 8.3 PPG, down from his previous performances. Then, everything came apart in 2015. The Rams finally gave Cook fewer targets with only 75, and he finished behind Tavon Austin in that category. Cook only caught 39 of those targets for 481 yards and no touchdowns, and he was the TE28 with a miserable 5.4 PPG.

2016: A Detour to Green Bay

After Cook’s awful 2015 season, the Rams decided they could no longer afford to pay Cook’s high salary and released him. At this stage in his career, Cook had never put up a single high-end fantasy season in seven years in the league. He also hadn’t made a significant impact for either of the NFL teams he played for, despite numerous chances and high target volume.

Therefore, Cook had to take a 1-year, $2.75 million prove-it deal with the Packers. When Cook signed with the Packers, fantasy owners celebrated as Cook would get to play with star quarterback Aaron Rodgers. In his seven seasons, Cook had never played with even an above-average quarterback, with Matt Hasselbeck and Nick Foles as the most notable on a very long list. Some thought that Cook would finally break out, even though he’d never really done that in seven years.

Unfortunately, Cook had the exact opposite of a breakout in 2016. Cook struggled through an injury-riddled season after breaking his foot in the offseason. He then played three games before suffering a high-ankle sprain in Week 3. Cook missed the following six games, but he never truly got going. In 10 games, he had 30 receptions on 51 targets for 377 yards and a touchdown. Cook averaged only 7.2 PPG, and he wasn’t a factor in fantasy football. 

Even if Cook’s injury was the cause of his poor play, the Packers decided to go in a different direction after 2016, signing Martellus Bennett to a massive contract in free agency. That decision left Cook out in the cold, having turned 30 years old in the 2017 offseason. Considering that Cook had now had three chances to produce and failed in all three, I had pretty much written Cook off after 2016. 

2017-2018: Late-Career Breakout

While I had no interest in Cook after 2016, the NFL still seemed to have an interest in him. Eventually, the Raiders signed Cook to a 2-year, $10.6 million contract to replace Clive Walford as their primary pass-catching tight end. At the time, the Raiders had two star wide receivers in Michael Crabtree and Amari Cooper, so Cook would be the clear third target in the offense behind them.

To Cook’s credit, he returned to full health in 2017 and played all 16 games, like he had done five previous times in his career. As expected, Cook was the third option for Derek Carr, and he caught 54 of 86 targets for 688 yards and two touchdowns. After two down years in 2015 and 2016, Cook returned to similar numbers he had recorded previously in his career. He was the TE12, averaged 8.3 PPG, and caught 62.8% of his targets. However, once again, Cook wasn’t the type of difference-maker that fantasy owners constantly seek at tight end. He was always usable but never great.

Through 2017, Cook had been a consistently average producer, both for NFL teams and fantasy owners. He had never finished higher than TE12 and had between 73 and 86 targets in five of his seven seasons as a starter. Therefore, I expected more of the same in 2018, where I predicted Cook to have another borderline TE1 season, despite turning 31 years old that April.

Cook shattered my prediction in 2018. He set career-highs in all receiving categories, bursting out for 68 receptions on 101 targets for 896 yards and six touchdowns. He also finally became an efficient player, catching 67.3% of his targets and averaging 8.9 yards/target, his best mark since 2011. 

While it’s hard to explain why Cook suddenly became efficient in 2018, it’s easy to see why he got more volume. Before 2018, the Raiders had moved on from Crabtree and replaced him with an aging Jordy Nelson. They also added Martavis Bryant in a trade from the Steelers. While Nelson was okay in his final season, Bryant was a complete bust. 

Also, the Raiders traded Cooper to the Cowboys in the middle of the season, leaving a massive void for targets. With no true top receiver, the Raiders had to rely on Cook and scatback Jalen Richard as receiving options, playing a dump-off style offense. Cook led the team in targets, although it wasn’t by design. The Raiders’ offense was just so bad that they couldn’t manage to run the ball or pass downfield, forcing Carr to target Cook heavily. However, I can’t ignore that Cook finally played well on the volume he got, although it’s odd it took nine years to see it.

After 2018, the Raiders bizarrely decided to let Cook go in free agency. As we know now, they made the right choice, as they had a great young tight end in Darren Waller stashed on the roster. However, at the time, it seemed like a red flag that the Raiders barely tried to retain Cook after his breakout 2018 campaign.

2019: The Most Bizarre Tight End Season Ever?

Once Cook hit free agency, the Patriots and the Saints competed to sign him, and Cook chose to sign with the Saints on a 2-year, $15 million contract. The Saints expected Cook to fill their longstanding void at receiving tight end and to add an element to the offense they hadn’t had since Jimmy Graham. Similar to his 2017 season in Oakland, Cook was now the clear third option in the Saints’ passing game, behind Michael Thomas and Alvin Kamara.

Cook had one of the most unique seasons I’ve seen for a tight end in 2019. He maintained his healthy catch rate from 2018, catching 66.2% of his targets, despite playing five games with Teddy Bridgewater instead of Drew Brees. Cook also improved to a stellar 10.8 yards/target, by far the top mark in his career. However, Cook’s raw stats significantly declined. He only had 43 receptions on 65 targets for 705 yards. Cook’s fantasy season got a significant boost from the nine touchdowns he scored, an insane number considering his target total, allowing him to finish as the TE7.

2020 and The Future

I find it hard to believe that Cook suddenly became a better red-zone player in 2019 when he had never been that effective there in his 10-year career. Therefore, I think Cook’s touchdown efficiency is a massive regression candidate going into 2020. The Saints still have Kamara and Thomas, and also signed Emmanuel Sanders in free agency. All of those players might compete with Cook for touchdowns, especially Kamara, who scored only one receiving touchdown in 2019. 

Cook is now 33 years old and has two successful fantasy seasons on his career resume. While those are his two most recent seasons, one happened due to volume he never saw previously, and the other occurred because of never-before-seen touchdown efficiency. Let’s not pretend that Cook magically became a different player after the age of 31. That’s not typical for an NFL player. More likely, Cook had two lucky seasons and is in for a significant shock of reality in 2020. Cook is my TE14, but I don’t even want him at that ranking. He has zero upside and will fail to live up to his draft price. Avoid him in 2020 and join me in watching Cook return to the player he was from 2009-2017, just without high target volume. That will be a disaster for his fantasy owners, and you’ll thank me for telling you to avoid it.

Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Karp. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.

Previous Dead to Me Articles: Dead to Me: Redraft, Dead to Me: Aaron Rodgers, Dead to Me: Sony Michel, Dead to Me: Tevin Coleman, Dead to Me: Marlon Mack, Dead to Me: Kerryon Johnson

Save to list