Open the Control Room

The WR1 Rating Dynasty Rookie Wide Receiver Countdown (Post Draft Update): Part 2

In this article, I update my annual WR1 rating scores with actual draft capital. This is the final update for these rookie wide receiver prospects.

For those new to the WR1 rating, this is a proprietary formula I developed to provide a data-driven forecast of future dynasty value for incoming rookie wide receivers. The WR1 model scores rookies on nine predictive metrics and then combines those individual metric scores into a single WR1 rating. The goal is to provide a single easy-to-use score for those who don’t want to spend all the time dissecting different metrics. 

Before the draft, I use projected draft capital from consensus mock draft resources like grindingthemocks.com. I then update the model with actual draft capital after the draft. As landing spot is subjective and factors involved with it change often, it does not figure into these rankings. This model is a formula generated purely from statistical facts.

You may find an in-depth explanation of the process and a glossary of what the metrics mean here. 

Here are the top 20 all-time prospects in the model so you can see how effective it is at forecasting future fantasy value.

Now we will reveal the ranks 10 – 6!

10) David Bell, Purdue (Pre NFL Draft Rank 10)

WR1 Rating   Conf.   Film Grade   Actual Draft Round   Early Declare   Relative Athletic Score   Breakout Age   Dominator Rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA Best  
Total Big 10 5.90 3 Yes 2.72 18.70 35.1% 22.9 2.39
18.0 2 0 0 5 -3 6 3 5 0

David Bell

The Good

David Bell burst onto the scene as a freshman playing alongside Rondale Moore at Purdue. He achieved a breakout (Over 20% share of his team’s receiving yardage and td production) his freshman year, compiling 86 receptions for 1035 receiving yards and a 25.2% target share. He is an early declare who has consistently produced, averaging 22.9 fantasy points per game throughout his college career.  That was the top PPR PPG in this draft class.

The Bad

Bell’s receiving yards per team pass attempt of 2.39 is lower than what you want from a top receiving prospect.  The top players in this class are 3.5 or greater. Film experts question his ceiling due to his lack of athleticism. Lance Zierlein recently changed Bell’s film grade from 6.11 to 5.90 after he tanked at the combine. This dropped Bell to zero points for his film grade. 

The Ugly

Bell smashed a lot of his fan’s dreams at the combine. His relative athletic score of 2.72 was very bad. Players like this rarely get drafted in the top two rounds. Jarvis Landry is the only recent wide receiver I could find drafted in the top two rounds with a lower relative athletic score. I will be updating the WR1 scores after the draft based on actual draft capital.

9)  Christian Watson, North Dakota State (Pre NFL Draft Rank 9)

WR1 Rating   Conf.   Film Grade   Actual

Draft

Round  

Early Declare   Relative Athletic Score   Breakout Age   Dominator Rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA Best  
Total MVFC 6.27 2 No 9.96 20.3 44.0% 9.0 3.12
19.0 -8 3 5 -5 15 -1 5 -5 10

Christian Watson

The Good

Watson was the leading receiver on the 2019 North Dakota State team which featured Trey Lance at quarterback. He vaulted up draft boards after a tremendous Senior Bowl week. He was named as the National team’s top receiver.  The Athletic reported him as “virtually uncoverable in one-on-one drills”

His size (6’4” 208 lbs), speed (4.36 forty yard dash) and vertical (38.5 inches) make him an attractive target for NFL general managers. This gave Watson a 9.98 relative athletic score  out of 10 which is the top in this class. Julio Jones, Calvin Johnson, Chase Claypool, and Andre Johnson are some other names in the top ten all-time for the relative athletic score. This peaked the interest of the Green Bay Packers who drafted Watson 34th overall giving him a premium landing spot.

Watson’s second strongest metric was his dominator rating of 44.0%. This is 90th percentile among prospects and ranked fifth overall.  The RYPTPA was solid at 3.12 contributing 10 points to his WR1 rating.  His projected second-round draft capital is also a highlight.

The Bad

Watson stayed all four years which subtracted five points vs if he had declared early. His PPR PPG was subpar for a top-level prospect at only 9.0 per game during his college career. The Bison were a run-heavy team who typically had big leads in games during Watson’s tenure, so Watson doesn’t have eye-popping volume stats.

The Ugly

The level of competition for NCAA’s Division I Football Championship Subdivision scored Watson negative eight points towards his WR1 rating score. Watson was a man among boys so it remains to be seen how he will fare vs bigger, stronger, faster athletes.

8) Skyy Moore, Western Michigan (Pre NFL Draft Rank 8)

WR1 rating   Conf.   Film grade   Actual

draft

round  

Early declare   Relative athletic score   Breakout age   Dominator rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA best  
Total MAC 6.24 2 Yes 7.54 20.00 44.8% 17.4 3.48
27.0 -5 3 5 5 0 4 5 0 10

Skyy Moore

The Good

Skyy Moore is a hot name post draft. As these rankings use no subjective metrics, landing spot is not factored in. The Kansas City one is juicy though being linked to Patrick Mahomes so you can easily make an argument for Moore as the WR 6 in the class. 

He is one of the most intriguing prospects in this class. Whatever Moore touches he catches. He has unusually large hands for someone 5’10”.

Moore is a G5 player declaring for the draft as a junior. That in and of itself should tell you how good Moore is. Western Michigan threw to Moore early and often. He had a 3.48 receiving yard per team pass attempt which was third-best in this class. He also led all prospects in yards per route run. The fact he excelled vs press coverage is a good sign for his ability to transition at the NFL level.

The Bad

Lance Zierlein’s film grade of 6.24 was not as high as some of the top prospects in this class. Lance described Moore as “courageous working into the teeth of the defense and tenacious to come up with contested catches from anywhere on the field. He’s a one-note route-runner lacking acceleration out of break points and vertical juice to separate deep. His ball skills and toughness create opportunities as a reliable target and capable route-runner from release to whistle.” 

The Ugly

The biggest red flag for Skyy Moore is his level of competition.  His production has been outstanding but it should be against Kent State and San Jose State.

7)  George Pickens, Georgia (Pre NFL Draft Rank: 6)

WR1 Rating   Conf.   Film Grade   Actual

Draft

Round  

Early Declare   Relative Athletic Score   Breakout Age   Dominator Rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA best  
Total SEC 6.23 2 Yes 9.35 18.5 32.4%* 12.9 2.1*
35.0 6 3 5 5 12 6 3 -5 0

George Pickens

The Good

Pickens utilized his excellent hands to break out during his freshman year with 727 yards receiving and eight touchdowns. This earned him the maximum six points for breakout age. Pickens went up against the best competition in the country playing in the SEC and the WR1 model rewards him for that with six points. He is an early declaration earning five points. Lastly, his relative athletic score of 9.35 was one of the top scores in this class. This earned him 12 points thanks in large part to his speed for a man 6’3” tall. Here is a clip of Pickens running his forty-yard dash at the combine. 

The Bad

Pickens is an interesting case study for analytics-based models given his ACL tear ruined what would have been his most productive year. Pickens best season receiving yards per team pass attempt (RYPTPA) was 1.75 but it was done as a freshman. He also achieved his best season dominator of 27.0% as a freshman. 

This is where we need to adjust for context as this was not an accurate reflection of his actual production. For this exercise, we added a conservative 20% to his freshman year dominator and RYPTPA to make these numbers more comparable to other prospects. The average prospect increase from freshman year to junior year is greater than 20% but I wanted to be conservative. This is further represented when you look at Pickens yards per route run. He did not run many routes his junior year but he posted a 3.34 YPRR which ranked sixth in the class.

The Ugly

Pickens performance suffered when he came back from his ACL tear in 2021. It is common for it to take some time before players return to their prior form. The PPR PPG is also less than we would like to see at 12.9.  As such, Pickens had five points deducted from his overall WR1 score in the dominator and PPR PPG metrics. 

6)  Wan’Dale Robinson, Kentucky (Pre NFL Draft Rank 7)

WR1 rating   Conf.   Film grade   Actual

draft

round  

Early declare   Relative athletic score   Breakout age   Dominator rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA best  
Total SEC 6.17 2 Yes 6.12 18.7 37.3% 18.5 3.64
40.0 6 3 5 5 -3 6 3 3 12

Wan’Dale Robinson

The Good

The WR1 model is a fan of Wan’Dale Robinson. His production profile matches up with the best in this class. Robinson is a dynamic playmaker. He will benefit most from an offense that can creatively find ways to get him in space as the 49ers have done with Deebo Samuel.  Wan’Dale achieved the maximum possible points available in the model in breakout age (18.7, six points) and conference (SEC, six points). Wan’Dale led all prospects in this class in RYPTPA at 3.64. This earned him 12 points toward his overall WR1 score.

The Bad

The projected third-round draft capital was expected to be a red flag for Robinson according to consensus mocks. However, he came out of the draft with a very impressive selection of 43rd overall by the New York Giants.

The Ugly

He is 5’8” tall. As @ChrisMiles1017 wrote about here, 19 players since 2013 have been drafted and shorter than 5’10” but only two have become hits. The game is changing though and the field is more spread out. Little guys like Elijah Moore and Rondale Moore could soon change that stat. This height was a key driver in Robinson’s low relative athletic score.  

The final rankings 5 – 1 will drop next, come back tomorrow to see!

I hope you enjoyed reading my article. My goal is to provide actionable advice you can utilize to improve your dynasty team. You can follow me on Twitter @force_fantasy.

Save to list