Open the Control Room

The WR1 Rating Dynasty Rookie Wide Receiver Countdown (Post Draft Update): Part 1

In this article, I update my annual WR1 rating scores with actual draft capital. This is the final update for these rookie wide receiver prospects.

For those new to the WR1 rating, this is a proprietary formula I developed to provide a data-driven forecast of future dynasty value for incoming rookie wide receivers. The WR1 model scores rookies on nine predictive metrics and then combines those individual metric scores into a single WR1 rating. The goal is to provide a single easy-to-use score for those who don’t want to spend all the time dissecting different metrics. 

Before the draft, I use projected draft capital from consensus mock draft resources like grindingthemocks.com. I then update the model with actual draft capital after the draft. As landing spot is subjective and factors involved with it change often, it does not figure into these rankings. This model is a formula generated purely from statistical facts.

You may find an in-depth explanation of the process and a glossary of what the metrics mean here. 

Here are the top 20 all-time prospects in the model so you can see how effective it is at forecasting future fantasy value.

Now we will reveal the 2022 prospect scores.

15) Tyquan Thornton, Baylor (Before NFL Draft Rank: Unranked)

WR1 Rating   Conf.   Film Grade   Actua.

Draft 

Round  

Early Declare   Relative Athletic Score   Breakout Age   Dominator Rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA best  
Total Big 12 5.97 2 No 8.56 20.5 37.5% 11.4 2.59
10.0 2 0 5 -5 8 -1 3 -5 3

Tyquan Thornton

The Good

Tyquan Thornton was a surprising 2nd round pick to say the least. I had multiple wide receivers with a better pre-draft grade. That said, he was awarded 5 points to his overall score for being picked 50th overall by the Patriots. When an organization invests significant draft capital in a player, they are likely to give that player more touches and chances than others with lower capital. Thornton is an absolute burner. He posted a 4.28 forty-yard dash which was tops in the class. His three-cone time was surprisingly slow at 7.25 but his elite straight-line speed still helped him to a strong showing for his relative athletic score of 8.56 out of 10.

The Bad

Outside of the athleticism, the other predictive metrics were mediocre for a player drafted in the second round. His college fantasy production was low relative to other top prospects as he averaged only 11.4 PPR fantasy points for his career. This subtracted 5 points from his overall WR1 score.

The Ugly

He was a late declare which is a big red flag. The hit rate for late declare prospects is far less than early declares. This is ultimately an indictment by the NFL saying you weren’t ready for the league after your junior year.

14) John Metchie, Alabama (Before NFL Draft Rank: 15)

WR1 Rating   Conf.   Film Grade   Actual

Draft 

Round  

Early Declare   Relative

Athletic Score  

Breakout Age   Dominator Rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA best  
Total SEC 6.18 2 Yes 7.5* Proj 21.1 22.6% 14.9 2.16
10.0 6 3 5 5 3 -8 -2 -2 0
John Metchie

The Good

Analytically, not much from Metchie’s profile suggests he will go on to have a top 24 fantasy WR type of career. The best thing he has going for him is that he played for Alabama in the SEC. Alabama has had a very competitive wide receiver room in recent years, so just making it there as a starter says something. Metchie was awarded six points for his overall WR1 model score for playing in the SEC. 

The Bad

You hear terms like polished, sophisticated, and advanced when it comes to Metchie’s film. This can also be code for a lower ceiling. He uses his advanced technique to manipulate corners and handled press coverage well at the college level. He received a film grade from Lance Zierlein  of 6.18 which contributed three of a maximum 15 towards his overall rating.

Metchie did not participate in the combine drills due to his ACL injury, so his relative athletic score is a projection. He has decent size and speed but does not possess elite NFL athlete traits. Metchie’s draft capital ended up being a little better than he was mocked. He was drafted in the second round by the Houston Texans.

The Ugly

Metchie didn’t breakout (achieve a 20% receiving yardage and touchdown share) until age 21. Granted, he did compete with Jaylen Waddle, Devonta Smith, and Jameson Williams for targets but that has not stopped great wide receivers from breaking out in the past. We also need to bear in mind that Williams barely saw the field at Ohio St. after being stuck behind Chris Olave and Garrett Wilson. Metchie may be a usable back-end fantasy starter in full PPR leagues as he projects as a slot receiver with higher reception potential vs yardage. The dominator rating of 22.6% is very weak, subtracting two points from his score. Lastly, Metchie suffered an ACL tear in December so we should expect a slower start until he gets back to his original form.

13) Alec Pierce, Cincinnati (Before NFL Draft Rank: 14)

WR1 Rating   Conf.   Film Grade   Actual

Draft 

Round  

Early Declare   Relative Athletic Score   Breakout Age   Dominator Rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA Best  
Total AAC 6.16 2 0 9.8 19.3 25.2% 10.3 2.21
10.0 -5 3 5 -5 15 4 -2 -5 0
Alec Pierce

The Good

Alec Pierce is an athletic marvel. He ran an impressive 4.41 forty-yard dash for a player of his size (6’3”, 211 lbs.) He also had a 40.5-inch vertical leap. This contributed to Pierce’s lofty relative athletic score (combined score based on key athletic measurables shown in the graphic below) of 9.8, earning him the maximum 15 points towards his overall WR1 rating. It is also this athleticism that has mock drafters projecting a second-round selection for Pierce.

Pierce is the type of high ceiling player I like to take a chance on in round three of dynasty rookie drafts vs a player like Metchie who projects to have a higher floor but a lower ceiling.

His special teams’ prowess will be attractive to teams and likely improved his draft capital but be wary of that, as it won’t help you in fantasy. 

The Bad

Pierce’s production was mediocre as compared to the best prospects across the board. His 25.2% dominator subtracted two points from his overall score, while his career PPR PPG gave him negative five points. Pierce’s receiving yards per team pass attempt (RYPTPA) of 2.21 was less than what we look for in future top 24 fantasy wide receivers.

The Ugly

Pierce is a late declare which typically means the NFL didn’t think he was ready to come into the league after his junior year. Pierce also played against weak competition in the American Athletic Conference which subtracted five points from his overall score. Overall, Pierce is still a bit rawer than some of the other prospects but he has the physical tools to be an impact player in the NFL.

12) Jalen Tolbert, South Alabama (Pre NFL Draft Rank: 12)

WR1 Rating   Conf. Film Grade   Actual

Draft

Round  

Early Declare   Relative Athletic Score   Breakout Age   Dominator Rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA Best  
Total Sun Belt 6.24 3 No 8.55 20.5 51.2% 15.6 3.63
15.0 -5 3 0 -5 8 -1 5 -2 12
Jalen Tolbert

The Good

Wow! That dominator rating pops off the page.  51.2% ranks first overall among 2022 prospects.  That contributes the maximum of five points to his WR1 rating. Tolbert landed in a nice spot in Dallas with a high-volume pass offense and a path to targets.  Tolbert’s RYPTPA impressively ranks second overall at 3.63. He is an excellent route runner who uses subtle techniques to create separation such as in the clip below. 

https://twitter.com/JetPackGalileo/status/1497791896839606274

Film like this is why Lance Zierlein gave Tolbert his seventh-highest film grade in the class.

The Bad

G5 early declares are rare but you still want to see it and unfortunately, Tolbert did not declare early. The early declaration is an endorsement from the NFL that you are going to receive significant draft capital. Tolbert’s breakout age of 20.5 is also a red flag. He should have been able to earn targets earlier in his career as an NFL-level prospect at South Alabama.

The Ugly

Tolbert played for South Alabama so he was going up against cornerbacks from Arkansas State and Georgia Southern. He gets negative five points for achieving his high level of production against weak competition relative to the other prospects. 

11) Jahan Dotson (Pre NFL Draft Rank: 11)

WR1 Rating   Conf.   Film grade   Actual

Draft

Round  

Early declare   Relative Athletic Score   Breakout Age   Dominator rating   PPR PPG Avg   RYPTPA Best  
Total Big 10 6.25 1 No 6.29 20.5 44.3% 14.8 2.88
15.0 2 3 13 -5 -3 -1 5 -2 3
Jahan Dotson

The Good

The mock draft and film community likes Jahan Dotson more than most analytics-based analysts. Lance Zierlein gave Dotson a film grade of 6.33 which is the sixth-highest in the class. He has excellent twitch and acceleration to get in and out of his breaks and create separation.

Here are some of his film highlights:

Dotson was consistently mocked on the fringe of round one through the first few months of the year. Turns out the mocks were correct as he was drafted in the first round by the Commanders. This is holding his WR1 rating together given him 13 of his 15 total points for the WR1 rating. That said, Dotson performed very well in dominator rating, earning five points with his 44.3% mark.

The Bad

Receiving yards per team pass attempt (RYPTPA) is one of the more predictive individual metrics in forecasting future fantasy production. Dotson posted a mediocre 2.88 which ranked tenth among the top prospects in the 2022 class. Dotson also was subpar in his relative athletic score, breakout age, and career PPR points per game.

The Ugly

Dotson played for four years in college which is a major red flag in my model. It deducts five points from the overall score vs. adding five points if they do declare early. This is a key signal of how ready the NFL feels the player is to make an impact.

Rankings 10 – 6 will drop next, followed by 5 – 1!

I hope you enjoyed reading my article. My goal is to provide actionable advice you can utilize to improve your dynasty team. You can follow me on Twitter @force_fantasy.

Save to list