Open the Control Room

Post Draft Superflex Rookie Mock

The DFF team recently did a post-draft superflex rookie mock. You can find the complete draft board here. If you want to compare this draft to our pre-draft mock, you can find our article series and the draft board at the bottom of the article. In this piece, I’m going to focus solely on my draft from the #9 slot. I want to dive into the four players I picked and concentrate on the value of those selections in the superflex dynasty format.

1.09: Justin Herbert (QB – LAC)

In superflex formats, quarterbacks are the lifeblood of your fantasy team. I rank Herbert seventh in my superflex rookie rankings, so I was thrilled to grab him at the 1.09. After going to the Chargers with the sixth overall pick, Herbert joins a loaded Chargers’ offense. He has Keenan Allen and Mike Williams as his top two receivers, Hunter Henry at tight end, and Austin Ekeler as a receiving threat from the backfield. Additionally, the Chargers drafted running back Joshua Kelley as a bruising complement to Ekeler, allowing Ekeler to focus on his role in the passing game.

I wrote about Herbert here, where I described him as a strong quarterback prospect. He would have been the QB2 in the 2019 class behind Kyler Murray and ahead of Daniel Jones and Dwayne Haskins, but he chose to return for his senior season at Oregon. Herbert’s main weakness is his lack of mobility, which will prevent him from having a high-end fantasy upside. However, he can make up for that with his strong arm and accurate passing ability. Considering his landing spot and the offensive weapons there, he has a great long-term future.

Given the events surrounding the coronavirus pandemic, rookies will have a tougher learning curve in 2020 than in a typical year. Therefore, I do think that Tyrod Taylor will start Week 1 for the Chargers, especially since he was on the team in 2019 and is already familiar with head coach Anthony Lynn’s offensive system. However, the Chargers spent a high-first round pick on Herbert, so they need to get him on the field shortly. Just like with Baker Mayfield in 2018, Taylor will be replaced in short order by a highly-drafted rookie quarterback, as Taylor provides no upside for the future of the Chargers.

The second Herbert steps onto the field as the starter, he will be worth more than the 1.09 I used to draft him. Even though I don’t expect him to succeed as a rookie, as I wrote about in my rookie preview, dynasty fantasy football is about trade value. Adding Herbert to your dynasty team is a great value pick. Therefore, this pick was a no-brainer for me.

2.09: Jordan Love (QB – GB)

Similar to Herbert, I felt that the value of Love was impossible to pass on at 2.09. The Packers selected Love with the 26th overall pick in the 2020 NFL Draft, making him the long-term successor to Aaron Rodgers. In my rookie quarterback preview, I stated that Love was not ready to play in 2020 and would tank all fantasy assets on his team if he ever saw the field. Rodgers will remain the Packers’ starter in 2020 and likely 2021, assuming he stays healthy.

I think that Love is a terrible quarterback prospect and should not have gone anywhere near the first round. He struggled with accuracy and threw 17 interceptions in his final college season. He couldn’t even dominate in the inferior Mountain West conference. Other than his build and big arm, I see nothing about Love that I like as a prospect. I would have preferred to have Jalen Hurts as a prospect over Love, and I think the Packers made a huge mistake, not only selecting Love but also trading up for him. However, now that they’ve done it, I believe they will find a way to move on from Rodgers sooner rather than later.

On that note, let’s take a look back at the history of quarterbacks selected in the first round of the NFL Draft. In 2018 and 2019, every first-round quarterback received an extended starting opportunity in their rookie year, with all of them starting at least seven games. While not all of them succeeded, they all had a chance to play. Their teams spent considerable draft capital to acquire them, and it makes sense that they saw the field to justify the team’s investment.

Even going back further, outside of Paxton Lynch, every single first-round quarterback since 2010 started a considerable number of games in their first or second year. That means that one first-round quarterback since 2010 would not have paid off the 2.09 draft price I picked Love. If a quarterback starts any considerable number of games in the NFL, they will be worth at least an early second-round rookie pick while they’re starting those games. Therefore, even though I can’t see how Love sees the field, the historical data means that I couldn’t let him slip past 2.09.

3.09: Jacob Eason (QB – IND)

Unlike Herbert and Love, Eason was a fourth-round selection, going to the Colts. The Colts already have Philip Rivers as their starting quarterback and Jacoby Brissett as the backup. Therefore, Eason will not see the field in 2020 unless both Rivers and Brissett suffer injuries.

However, both Rivers and Brissett have contracts that expire after 2020. The Colts have already seen enough from Brissett to know that he isn’t their long-term answer at quarterback. He’s had two stints as the starter for an entire season in 2017 and 2019, and he failed in both attempts. In his career, Brissett has completed only 59.9% of his passes and has averaged only 6.6 yards per attempt. While he’s taken care of the ball, throwing 31 touchdowns compared to 13 interceptions, he hasn’t shown any upside.

Rivers signed a 1-year, $25 million contract with the Colts in free agency, so he will undoubtedly start for all of 2020. Rivers is already 38 years old, so he probably has at most two years remaining. The Colts drafted multiple offensive weapons in running back Jonathan Taylor and wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. They also have one of the best offensive lines in the league and traded their first-round pick to the 49ers to acquire star defensive tackle, DeForest Buckner. 

Therefore, the Colts are all-in for 2020. If everything goes well, I expect the Colts to retain Rivers for 2021 and attempt to extend their championship window for one more season. On the other hand, if they falter and Rivers plays poorly, they could easily clean house at quarterback going into 2021. While they could draft a rookie from the 2021 class, they will likely win a few too many games to have a top selection. If they can’t get one of the top quarterback prospects, they might have to see what they have in Eason. Even though it’s a long-shot, Eason has a path to a starting job in 2021. Because of that, I was happy to grab him at 3.09.  

4.09: Lamical Perine (RB – NYJ)

Perine wasn’t a particularly exciting prospect coming out of Florida. He never carried the full workload in college and averaged only 5.0 yards per carry. The most exciting part of his profile is that he caught 40 passes for 262 yards and five touchdowns in his senior season in 2019. Based on those receptions, the Jets decided to select him in the fourth round.

The Jets have a barren depth chart behind workhorse starter Le’Veon Bell. In 2019, Bilal Powell and Ty Montogmery backed up Bell, and the Jets decided to retain neither of those players going into 2020. Therefore, Perine comes in as the immediate handcuff to Bell and will be his direct backup in 2020. Since Adam Gase still coaches the Jets, I’m not particularly excited about Perine. However, if Bell breaks down and misses time, Perine is a running back that will see opportunity. Therefore, he makes a nice dynasty stash for that potential rise in value.

Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Karp. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.

Pre-Draft Mock Links: Pre-Draft SF Mock Round 1, Pre-Draft SF Mock Round 2, Pre-Draft SF Mock Round 3, Pre-Draft SF Mock Round 4, Draftboard

Save to list