To continue my “A Look Back” series, I want to go back even further than the 2019 regular season and go to some of my pre-2019 Draft content. If you’re interested in my previous work in that series, the links are at the bottom of the article. In the summer of 2019, I did a two-part article, looking at tight end targets and avoids for 2019. Let’s start with how I did with the three players I picked as targets for the 2019 redraft season. The original article used a half-PPR format, so I’ll use half-PPR results for 2019 to evaluate myself.
Evan Engram
ADP: 61 overall, TE5
Result: TE18, TE7 in fantasy PPG in eight games played
I already broke down Engram’s 2019 season in decent depth in my Dead to Me article about him. While I won’t rehash all of that, Engram had an interesting 2019 season. Through five weeks, he was the TE2, just behind Austin Hooper, and looked like a smashing value at his TE5 ADP. In those five weeks, he had 33 receptions on 48 targets for 373 yards and two touchdowns.
Unfortunately for Engram, he missed Week 6 with an MCL injury. He did return for Weeks 7-9, but he wasn’t the same player. He totaled just 11 receptions for 94 yards and a touchdown in those three games. After Week 9, Engram missed the rest of the season with a foot injury, killing his fantasy owners.
So, how did I do with Engram? In my original article, I stated that Engram would benefit from increased targets in the offense after the departure of Odell Beckham, Jr. Through five weeks, when Engram was healthy, my prediction looked pretty accurate. Unfortunately, Engram’s injury woes took him down and prevented him from continuing his excellent start.
Additionally, Golden Tate missed the first four games to suspension, and Darius Slayton had not yet emerged in the Giants’ offense. While I couldn’t have possibly predicted Slayton’s rise, we never got to see Engram, Sterling Shepard, Tate, and Slayton all in the offense at the same time. When Engram performed well, he had just Shepard to compete for targets. We don’t know what a fully healthy Engram would have done for the remainder of the season.
Overall, I think that my recommendation of Engram was a decent choice. However, I believe an essential writing lesson is the biggest takeaway here. When I wrote this tight end article, I felt forced to include a higher tier tight end in my recommendations. I specifically said that Travis Kelce, George Kittle, and Zach Ertz were off the table but gave myself the freedom to choose anyone else. In the article, I stated that I felt that none of the second tier of tight ends were good values, including Engram as well as O.J. Howard, Eric Ebron, and Hunter Henry. None of those players paid off in 2019. Therefore, going forward, I should focus less on article format and more on making the best recommendation possible for my readers.
Vance McDonald
ADP: 81 overall, TE9
Finish: TE32, TE39 in fantasy PPG in 14 games played
Coming into 2019, McDonald was one of the most popular mid-round tight end targets in redraft formats. He had finished as the TE10 in 2018 and inherited a full-time role for 2019 after the departure of Jesse James in free agency. Many fantasy owners expected McDonald to take a further step forward and be a consistent, reliable fantasy producer in 2019.
Unfortunately for McDonald, we never got to see what he would have done in 2019. After Week 2, Ben Roethlisberger missed the rest of the season with an injury, forcing the Steelers to turn to backups Mason Rudolph and Devlin Hodges. In the two games McDonald played with Roethlisberger, he wasn’t that bad. He had nine receptions on 11 targets for 78 yards and two touchdowns. He was the TE5 after two weeks. Even so, most people had expected him to have a more significant role in the offense, with his target and yardage totals lowered than expected. Instead, wide receivers James Washington and Diontae Johnson both emerged as targets behind Juju Smith-Schuster, diluting McDonald’s share of the offense.
For the rest of the season, however, things took a turn from disappointing to ugly. McDonald played in 12 more games, never exceeding three receptions or 40 yards in any game. In those 12 contests, he totaled a pitiful 29 receptions on 44 targets for 195 yards and only one touchdown. McDonald finished fifth on the Steelers in targets behind Washington, Johnson, Smith-Schuster, and receiving back Jaylen Samuels. This performance was a far cry from the secondary target that he profiled as coming into 2019.
In retrospect, my recommendation of McDonald looks particularly poor. First, I said that I would far prefer McDonald to the two tight ends going right above him, Eric Ebron and Jared Cook. While Ebron just barely finished better than McDonald at TE27, Cook was the TE7 in 2019. Telling my readers to pass on Cook for McDonald hurt them pretty badly.
Additionally, I believe McDonald’s bust season carries a further lesson for fantasy owners: grabbing a top tier tight end is a strong strategy. Every year, there is a middle-tier tight end that carries hype and projects to have a massive breakout season. In 2018, it was Trey Burton, and in 2019 it was McDonald. Often, neither these breakout candidates nor the established middle-tier tight ends work out. As I mentioned in my TE streamer review, found at the bottom, streaming the tight end position is a fantasy football nightmare. Therefore, fantasy owners should value the best tight ends very highly, and they shouldn’t rely on finding someone in the middle rounds.
Jordan Reed
ADP: 159 overall, TE18
Result: N/A, missed entire season
Unlike Engram and McDonald, there is little to say about Reed. My article came out on August 1st. At the time, I felt that Reed could outperform his TE18 price, given that he had a history of TE1 seasons. Unfortunately for Reed, he suffered another concussion in the third preseason game. While he initially was expected to return for the season opener, he never managed to take the field for the Redskins in 2019. Reed’s career is likely over due to his history of concussions.
The main lesson to take away from Reed is that fantasy drafts should take place after the third preseason game. That way, almost all preseason injuries will have already occurred, and all fantasy owners will have the greatest opportunity to draft fairly. In the DFF Redraft Championship, I wasted picks on both Reed and Lamar Miller, both of whom suffered injuries in the preseason.
Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Justin. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.
Previous Look-Back Articles:
