Open the Control Room

DFF Rookie Round Table, Part 6: Bryan Edwards

After recently releasing my rookie rankings, I wanted to open up the floor to constructive criticism.  I also wanted to see where I was not aligned with other DFF analysts. So, we conducted a round table discussion. This discussion is now a 10-part series of informal articles. In these articles, analysts debate why some of their favorite rookie(s) should be moved up. And in one case, moved down!  

We debated the rankings on Jalen Reagor, Henry Ruggs, Tee Higgins, Joe Burrow, Tua Tagovailoa, AJ Dillon, Bryan Edwards, Antonio Gandy-Golden, Zack Moss, and Joshua Kelley. We also touched upon players in their range, and who should be ascending or descending. I want to give a big thanks to everyone who contributed to this series of articles. I urge you to go follow them on twitter.  Read the whole series for a number of opinions on players who could win you fantasy championships for years to come.

This is Part 6 of the series, where @ff_spaceman and I discuss rookie Bryan Edwards.

Rookie Bryan Edwards, overall rank 22, WR10

@ff_spaceman on why Edwards should be ranked higher: 

Bryan Edwards should be ranked higher when considering his college profile, and landing spot, when compared to other 2020 rookie WRs.

College Profile: He easily meets the thresholds for successful WRs in the NFL. Drafted in round 1-3 of the NFL Draft (3rd round), check. Age 18-20 breakout age (age 17 breakout), check. 0.7 career average scrimmage yards per team play (0.90), check. This quick and simple methodology has an 83% drafting accuracy for all WRs since 2003. Looking a little closer at Edwards, he was an excellent athlete coming out of high school. At age 17 he had a 103.9 (68th percentile for incoming rookies) height-adjusted speed score and a 37.5” vertical jump. It’s reasonable to assume (I know when I assume I make an ass out of you and me) that his draft capital could have been higher if he hadn’t broken his foot training for the NFL Combine.

Additionally, while at South Carolina, Edwards was only marginally outproduced by Deebo Samuel. Deebo Samuel was three years older than him at the time. When adjusting their college production for age, it’s fair to say Edwards had significantly better college production than Deebo. On the field, Edwards is very skilled at high-pointing the ball and using his strength to win in contested-catch situations. Then, after he catches the ball, he turns into a running back. He is excellent at creating yards after the catch. His detractors will say that Edwards was used at a high rate and had a low aDOT for the Gamecocks. However, this was the result of truly terrible QB play by the revolving door of South Carolina Quarterbacks. 

NFL Landing Spot: Edwards was selected by the Las Vegas Raiders. A team without a true number one wide receiver. In 2020, he will be competing with Henry Ruggs, Tyrell Williams, Hunter Renfrow, and Darren Waller for targets from Derek Carr (or hopefully Marcus Mariota). This is probably one of the softer landing spots for a rookie wide receiver in the NFL. It is within the realm of possibility that Edwards is the best pass-catcher out of this group. While I do like Henry Ruggs more than most analytically-minded analysts, the lack of a breakout age and his boom-bust profile is a concern. Waller and Renfrow produced on a team that lacked overall receiving talent after the departure of Antonio Brown. Additionally, Jon Gruden’s ultra-west-coast style offense favors lower aDOT receivers. We have seen Edwards produce in this style of offense before.

In conclusion, Bryan Edwards’ profile and landing-spot are rock solid, with room for substantial upside. His combined landing-spot, age-adjusted production, athleticism, and draft capital should place him ahead of many players in Edwards’ draft range.      

@DYNASTYDIAGNOS1 counter:

This is awesome stuff, Spaceman! Let’s address the elephant in the room first, which is his broken foot. The timeline for recovery from a broken foot is 8-12 weeks. This time has already passed. Yet there has been no news, that I’m aware of, that Edwards is now 100% healthy. This is likely due to the pandemic. Additionally, Edwards does have a significant injury history. Along with the broken foot, he suffered a meniscus tear in November. He also suffered a concussion and a sports hernia surgery back in 2017. Despite all of this, Edwards finished with the third-most receptions and fourth-most receiving yards in SEC history.  And he did so with terrible QB play. Edwards is certainly skilled — “the proof is in the pudding”.

Before drafting Edwards, the Raiders used a top-15 pick on Henry Ruggs. So, despite whatever analytics twitter thinks of Ruggs, the Raiders clearly regard him very highly. Already on the Raiders offense are Darren Waller and Tyrell Williams.  Both of whom solidified themselves as the top options in 2019. Before taking Edwards at 81, the Raiders also selected Lynn Bowden Jr.  Bowden was selected one pick before Edwards, and neither was involved in a trade on draft day. So, let’s call their draft capital equal. Hunter Renfrow is the point in the offense where you can begin the argument that Edwards is superior right now. However, because of the pandemic, all rookies will have a harder time earning opportunities on game day. Being the third pass-catcher drafted on a sub-optimal offense, Edwards may be the most severely impacted by this.

Let’s assume that veterans will retain their target percentage from last season. Namely, Waller, Williams, Renfrow, and Josh Jacobs. Let’s also assume that the Raiders’ improved receiver room will lead to more passes overall. Let’s say Carr returns to his career average of 552 attempts. Those four players make up 51% of the targets. This also does not take into account Jalen Richard, Jason Witten, and Zay Jones. Let’s keep Richard steady at 43 and  Jones at 25.  We will put Witten at 50 (which is a conservative number made up of Foster Moreau and Derek Carrier’s 2019 targets). This leaves only 155 targets for the rookie trio. A conservative projection for Ruggs is 85 targets. Then we can split the remaining 70 targets down the middle.

If we are projecting 35 targets for Bryan Edwards, let’s use the best possible situation for those targets. Derek Carr’s most efficient relevant figures are his 2019 completion percentage of 70.9%, his 2015 TD rate of 5.6%, and his yards-per-attempt of 2019 which was 7.9-yards. This leaves Bryan Edwards with a rookie stat line of 25 receptions for 277-yards and 2 TDs. This is a generous projection when compared to Mike Clay’s projection for Edwards of only 15 targets and 10 receptions for 123-yards and 1 TD.

Based on the athletic profile, and Edwards’ collegiate production in the toughest conference in America, Edwards is a top-end prospect. However, the landing spot and expected rookie year production push Edwards down in rookie rankings. Bryan Edwards is going to be an excellent buy-low during the season. Next offseason, the acquisition price will certainly be lower than the second-round pick that I currently have him at. As well as lower than the borderline first-round pick that you have indicated he may be worth. I do not agree that on this basis Edwards should be ranked higher.  However, it is worth investigating whether some ranked above him should be lowered.

Conclusion

Edwards has a great prospect profile. However, barring a number of injuries in the Raiders’ receiving core, he does not have a clear path to production in 2020. The Raiders can theoretically cut Tyrell Williams, and his $11,500,000 yearly salary, in 2021 with no dead cap. Consider trading for Edwards toward the end of this year. His value should be significantly lower, and you won’t have to use your draft capital in your rookie draft.

It is worth noting that Edwards is the final piece of the Khalil Mack trade. The Raiders essentially traded Khalil Mack for Josh Jacobs, Blessuan Austin, Damon Arnette, and Bryan Edwards.

Thank you for reading our article! If you would like to debate any of the above, reach out to us on twitter.  And I hope you join me and @DFF_Karp for “Rookie Round Table Part 7: Antonio Gandy-Golden”.

The rest of this informal Rookie Round Table Discussion can be found here: Part 1: Jalen Reagor, Part 2: Henry Ruggs III, Part 3: Tee Higgins, Part 4: Joe Burrow and Tua Tagovailoa, Part 5: AJ Dillon

Keep an eye out for my future articles. You can find my previous articles in the Dynasty Football Factory archive. You can also follow us on Twitter. @DynastyDiagnos1,@RookieWhisper, @ff_walrus, @WillieBeamanDFF, @DynastyTripp, @DFF_Ztrain, @ff_spaceman, @DFF_Karp, and @CKarayannides.

Save to list