Open the Control Room
Sean Tucker

2023 Dynasty Rookie Draft Strategy

Spring is one of my favorite times of year but not for the same reasons as most people. Spring is the climax of rookie draft research season. As the snow begins to subside, it means the Senior Bowl is upon us. When we put the heavy down jacket into storage, it marks the calendar for the NFL Combine. Blades of glass emerge from the ground as NFL Free Agency ramps up. As we see Zay Flowers in full bloom, we have all the pomp and circumstance of the NFL Draft.

In this article, I want to take you through some rookie draft strategies and illuminate how you should maneuver around the draft board. Overall this class is a little short on elite talent but has exceptional depth well until the third round. It also contains a “dead zone” where I am looking to either trade up or trade back while acquiring future assets. I will walk you through the draft board utilizing our DFF AccuADP Tool and let you know where I see the value.

Before we get into the specific strategy for this there are a few tenets I go into each draft with:

  1. Always draft talent over situations or need
  2. Take the value vs reaching for “your” guy
  3. Know the market average draft position to get in range for targeted players
  4. Rookie picks are at their most valuable during the draft. Make trades!

First and foremost, you need to get yourself into a position to nail that top team selection. This class is shaping up to have four blue-chip prospects. I am trying to get myself into a position to get one of these top four rookies.

 

The “Generational” Prospect (1.01)

Bijan Robinson 

Robinson stands alone atop this draft. Contending teams should be chomping at the bit to add Robinson to their teams. The only way you should expect to be able to do that is to acquire the 1.01. In most leagues, the 1.01 is held by a rebuilding team. Rebuilding teams usually don’t want to take a running back until they are ready to contend. Therefore, you may find a willing trade partner. As the running back position continues to be diluted by timeshares, having a true three-down bellcow back allows you to have a prized positional differentiator.

The “Blue Chip” Trio (1.02 to 1.04)

Bryce Young, C.J. Stroud, Jaxon Smith-Njigba

After Bijan, we have two of the three blue-chip quarterbacks. This is a solid quarterback class overall. It far exceeds 2022 where only Kenny Pickett went in the first round and was a later pick. We should see up to four quarterbacks drafted in the Top 10 of the NFL Draft.

You need to be prepared for three of those (Young, Stroud, and Richardson) to go in the top five picks overall. The order they will go will vary among leagues. I prefer Young and Stroud to Richardson. In leagues where I need a quarterback, I am attempting to position myself at 1.03 and take who remains of Stroud and Young. Both are highly proven prospects at the highest level of competition in college and have been at the top of this class since they were freshman recruits.

As for Jaxon Smith-Njigba, he is as a can’t-miss wide receiving prospect as there has been to enter the NFL since Ja’Marr Chase. I can not recall another situation where we had an incoming rookie wide receiver who had outproduced the two most productive NFL rookies while all three were playing for the same team in college. His athleticism was thought to be a potential red flag but then he crushed the Combine and Pro Day displaying elite short-area quickness. Smith-Njigba posted the 4th best 20-yard shuttle since 2007. 

In my proprietary WR1 Analytics Model which accurately forecasts a player’s future Dynasty success based on a recipe of nine predictive metrics, Smith-Njigba posted a stellar score of 69. This crushed every other wide receiver in this class and gives him a 91.7% chance of posting a future top-24 fantasy season. I have been saying this off-season his 3.25 receiving yards per team pass attempt as a 19-year-old sophomore playing alongside Junior Garrett Wilson and Senior Chris Olave is one of the most impressive single data points I have ever seen.

Jahmr Gibbs

The “Towering Ceiling” Duo (1.05 to 1.06)

Jahmyr Gibbs, Anthony Richardson

Gibbs and Richardson are a tantalizing duo of prospects in the top six. These two have immense league-winning type ceilings. But both also have significantly lower floors than the three blue-chip prospects.

The term generational is thrown around too much. However, with the top relative athletic score for a quarterback of all-time we can comfortably say Anthony Richardson is a generational athlete at the quarterback position. If his superpowers can be harnessed he could vault himself into that elite tier of Konami quarterbacks. 

Many Dynasty managers will fall in love with Richardson and take him top three meaning there is a chance Young or Stroud will fall to 1.04. Richardson is a good ceiling play. I would pair Richardson with a high-floor player such as Kirk Cousins.

Likewise, Gibbs posted an elite target share in college of 14.7%. This was in the 93rd percentile for running backs. Gibbs can be a cheat code in Dynasty The question that remains though is how much of a role he will have. Many believe he is destined for a timeshare.

Devon Achane

The “Robin” Tier (1.07 to 2.01)

Zach Charbonnet, Will Levis, Jordan Addison, Quentin Johnston, Josh Downs, Devon Achane, Michael Mayer

Not everyone can be Batman and that is just fine. Batman wouldn’t have been near as successful in thwarting Gotham City’s villainous underworld without his faithful sidekick Robin. Our Dynasty teams need Robin’s to win as well. The “Robin’s” listed above all have their warts but should end up being solid contributors to your Dynasty squad. Some are small (Achane and Downs). Some are slower than we would like to see (Mayer and Addison) Some are just not spectacular (Charbonnet and Johnston). 

Downs is one of my favorite targets of this group at the end of the first or beginning of the second round. If I see him dropping into the second I will be making an effort to trade up and grab him.  As you will see, I am not a big fan of the value presented in the next group of players. Therefore, if I am holding a mid-second I will bundle it with an asset to go get Downs. 

When analyzing wide receiver prospects, analysts such as myself, like to check boxes when a player eclipses a designated threshold for a certain metric. No prospect in this class checked more of these boxes across all metrics than Josh Downs. Downs was an uber-producer during his time at Chapel Hill. When Sam Howell or Drake Maye needed a big play, Downs was the unquestioned target. Downs’s best season RYPTPA is 3.52. This is the highest score for RYPTPA of any prospect in this class. 10 of the top-12 all-time WR1 model prospects and 21 of the top-24 WR1 prospects had the best season RYPTPA above 3.0.

Lastly, there is Will Levis. Levis is extremely polarizing but if he gets top-10 draft capital he will go in the first round of rookie drafts. The economics of Dynasty make starting quarterbacks a highly desirable asset. They are simply short in supply, which makes them high in demand. If there is one thing we have learned about high first-round quarterbacks over the years it is that they will get every chance to prove they can not play at the NFL level.

Zach Evans

The “Dead” Zone (2.02 to 2.11)

Jalin Hyatt, Zay Flowers, Tank Bigsby, Sean Tucker, Zach Evans, Kayshon Boutte, Kendre Miller, Dalton Kincaid, Marvin Mims, Roschon Johnson

This is an area I am trying to trade out of in my leagues. The month leading up to your rookie draft and when you are actually on the clock during the draft are the two points in time when rookie picks are at their peak value. These are players going in the second round of current rookie mock drafts that offer little talent separation from those going in the third round. 

Therefore, I am approaching this section of the draft with four strategies:

  1. Package one of these mid-seconds with another asset to try to move into the first round, 
  2. Trade one of these picks for a quality veteran that is a known asset and can contribute to my roster.
  3. Move one of these picks for a third-rounder plus an asset
  4. Move one of these picks for a 2024 pick

Israel Abanikanda

The “Rollback Specials” (2.12 to 3.06)

Israel Abanikanda, Chase Brown, Luke Musgrave, Sam LaPorta, Cedric Tillman, Hendon Hooker, Tyjae Spears

Unlike the prior group, this may be my favorite group of players in rookie drafts this year. What this class lacks in elite talent it makes up for with superior depth. At the time of this writing, these are all players going in the third round of rookie mock drafts as documented in our DFF AccuADP.

What makes it particularly attractive is the quality of running back that is still available. Running back is already a good position to target in the third round of any Dynasty Rookie Draft. All it takes is an injury to a starter and these picks will reap value. In this particular draft, these running backs are of the quality where an injury may not even be necessary.

Abanikanda has been one of my top targets in rookie mock drafts for the last few months. I love the value he presents at this current ADP. However, I fear this will continue to rise after he crushed his Pro Day.

Abanikanda has been a riser in this draft process. He had elite production last year with 1,431 yards rushing and 20 rushing TDs. This was good for a 97th percentile dominator rating. His 5’11, 216 lbs. size is perfect for the NFL grind.

Israel Abanikanda RAS

Luke Musgrave was one of my favorite tight-end sleepers before the Combine. Unfortunately, his Combine performance woke everyone up. A 9.77 relative athletic score is ridiculously good.  There is a significant correlation between athleticism and future success at the tight end position. Eight of the 11 tight ends with two or more top 5 fantasy finishes since 2007 had a RAS above 9.0. 

Musgrave only played in two games for Oregon St. this year and was their leading receiver in both. He averaged 85 yards per game. Musgrave posted a ridiculous 3.31 receiving yards per team pass attempt in that tiny sample. Add a best-in-class Lance Zeirlein film grade of 6.7 and consider me all in on Musgrave. Musgrave should be a locked-in top-three tight end in Dynasty Rookie Drafts now. Look for him to be selected by round two of the NFL Draft.

Luke Musgrave RAS

For some reason, not a lot of people are talking about Chase Brown. 

Brown was only a three-star recruit with offers from programs like South Dakota and McNeese St. He ended up at Western Michigan during his freshman year before transferring to Illinois. He continued to progress throughout his college career culminating in outstanding production in his final two years for Illinois. Brown ran for 1005 yards in 2021 and was 4th in the NCAA in rushing yards for 2022 with 1,643 yards.

Now he posts an elite 9.62 relative athletic score with nice body density at 5’9 and 209 lbs. to take the NFL pounding. You need to be in on Chase Brown in the late second to the mid-third round of Dynasty Rookie Drafts.

In Daniel Jeremiah’s latest mock draft 3.0, he also had Hendon Hooker as a late first-rounder. If this happens he will not drop out of the second round in Dynasty Rookie Drafts.

Tank Dell

The “Underdogs” (4th and 5th Round Sleepers)

Nathaniel Dell, Andrew Iosivas, Zach Kuntz

Everyone loves a good underdog story. Dynasty Rookie Draft fourth and fifth-rounders are long shots to contribute to your Dynasty teams. In the fourth and fifth rounds, I like to target players with elite traits with the hopes that they will be molded by NFL artisans into finished works of art.

Nathaniel Dell is my favorite Underdog in this class. I wrote extensively about him here. There is no getting around it. Dell is tiny. If Anthony Richardson is this class’s Thor, Dell is Ant-Man. But the NFL has been prioritizing talent over prototype size in recent years. Players such as Jaylen Waddle, Rondale Moore, DeVonta Smith, Justin Jefferson, and Chris Olave are ushering in a new archetype of wide receiver that is far from the Julio Jones and Calvin Johnson’s of years past. These players, like Dell, win with exceptional agility and precise route running.

Kuntz is purely an athletic freak. In Kent Lee Platte’s Relative Athletic Score, Kuntz scored a perfect 10, He sat behind Pat Freiermuth at Penn St. before finishing out his career at Old Dominion. 

Zack Kuntz RAS

Iosivas is a bit of an under-the-radar prospect but will certainly become more renowned with this Combine performance. He comes from the Ivy League so his competition is certainly suspect. But he did show he was more than just an uber athlete while at Princeton.

Andrei I RAS

To go with this 9.95 Relative Athletic Score he also posted an impressive 2.70 receiving yards per team pass attempt. Iosivas is someone I will be watching closely on draft day. I have him as a third-rounder right now after this Combine performance. If that is the case he will be on my radar as a target in the third rounds of rookie drafts. This late in rookie drafts I like to target prospects with elite physical traits. If they can figure out how to use those traits you might have something.

Thank you for joining me on this journey as we navigate through the various tributaries of this 2023 Dynasty Rookie Draft. Follow your strategic roadmap, put yourself in the right locations and you will eventually reach your ultimate destination of a Dynasty league championship.

I hope you enjoyed reading my article. My goal is to provide actionable advice you can utilize to improve your Dynasty team. You can follow me on Twitter @force_fantasy. #DFFArmy #FantasyFootball #AlwaysBeBuilding #NFL #NFLDraft #NFLTransactions #NFLTrades #AlwaysBeScouting #PlantYourFlag

Save to list