In this piece, I will be directly responding to a recent post by @Heady_Football in which he describes his ideal redraft draft strategy. In his article, which you can find here, he states that you should start your draft with three straight running backs while waiting on the other positions like wide receiver, tight end, and quarterback. I am here to tell you why I think there are better strategies to employ. So, after reading both you will truly be able to decide what you think is best.
The Strategy
Heady’s general principle is that the difference in scoring between RB1 and RB24 over the last six years is 15 fantasy points per game. However, only one person gets the RB1. Let’s look at 2020 for example, Christian McCaffrey averaged 27.6 points in .5 PPR scoring while the RB 24 averaged 12.2. That is about what was said by Heady, a 15 point difference. Although, the RB5, Aaron Jones averaged 16.7 ppg which is only 4.5 more than the RB24. Using the RB1 as a comparison to the RB24 is misleading because the top couple RBs are much more productive than even back half RB1s.
So, let’s say you have a late or mid-round first. Instead of getting a guy that’s averaging over 20 points per game and providing a 10+ ppg increase over replacement, you are getting a guy that only offers a small boost over the RB24.
Now that we explained that, let’s think about what it takes to win a fantasy game. Because we can not get to the playoffs if we do not win regular-season games. In fantasy, we need consistent scoring. That way we can reliably set our lineups every week and know about what to expect. I do not have concrete data on what I am about to describe but intuitively it makes sense and @LateRoundQB has discussed it on his podcast. It is ADP vs weekly scoring by position. He looked at players over the last 10 seasons and compared players’ ADP vs their weekly scoring output (or consistency) by position.
What he found was that running back was generally predictable even into the late thirties. While at wide receiver the top end guys were very predictable, the middle and late-round wide receiver picks were far less predictable every week. With Heady’s strategy, you would be getting predictable RBs but sacrificing at WR by having unpredictable players who could lose you your week. While if you spend at WR early and grab guys who will be predictable, you can follow them up with predictable and productive RBs in the middle rounds.
The next thing Heady did was outline some players/teams he was drafting from different draft slots. I will post what could have been done if he went wide receiver/TE early instead of RB.
Early First Round Pick
Heady would take players like Dalvin Cook in the early first and, while I also think it is a good idea to take a running back in the top half of the draft, I think we should go for it 100% and take Kelce. Heady did not outline what RBs he was taking at the two-three turn from this draft slot because “it left me wanting more for my second running back”. So, it sounds like to me he was not a fan of the choices there. While, with my strategy, we can happily grab guys like Justin Jefferson and Keenan Allen to round out our WR core.
At the next turn, Heady said he would grab WRs like CeeDee Lamb or Robert Woods, who are some solid options for sure. We will be grabbing Myles Gaskin and Tyler Lockett though, to secure a workhorse RB and get our third WR.
At the six-seven turn, Heady mentions Tee Higgins as his WR three and later mentions Robby Anderson who has an ADP around here so let’s plug him in. We will be soaking up the RB value by grabbing Mike Davis and Chase Edmonds. This gives us three running backs who all project to be heavily involved in the passing games, but Mike Davis and Myles Gaskin also figure to see 200 or more carries and should be considered workhorses.
The start I drafted can compete with any RBs Heady drafted. My WRs outshine him, although I will admit not by much. Lastly, Kelce just provides a supreme advantage over any player he can pick. Plus, with only one flex spot in most redraft leagues, Heady has already drafted two bench players who will not be scoring him points while I completed my positional lineup by round six and I can start adding RB depth. Guys like Trey Sermon, Ronald Jones, Michael Carter, Damien Harris, and Zack Moss are all still available to add good depth. Since I spent high on WR I know I can play my guys each week with no worry, while I can use my RB depth to play the matchups and find upside there.

Mid First Round Pick
Since I have already gone over a lot of my reasonings previously in the article, I will just post the team that Heady drafted vs the team I drafted with our different strategies. Then I will talk about the differences between them. Heady did not give any details past the fifth round, but that is fine – we can still compare them.
Heady got an elite guy in Zeke, but Gibson and Monty fall in that low-end RB1 to mid RB2 category where all the players are similar. His WRs are solid but both will be mid WR2s flirting with low-end WR1 spike weeks. Davante Adams and Stefon Diggs both have a real shot to be the overall WR1 in 2021 and should both be top five at the position. Again, I grabbed an early tight end to give me a huge advantage over whoever Heady grabs, and finished it off with a plethora of running backs that will see a lot of touches and who I can just play matchups with. My RBs should be able to compete with Heady’s and keep it close, while my WRs and TE blow his doors off.

Wow, you read all the way through! Thank you, I appreciate you using your time to enjoy my content. If you would like to talk to me about my article or ask me any generic dynasty or trade questions, you can find me on Twitter @ChrisMiles1017, DFF Draft Director. Shoot me a DM, they are always open. Come join the #DFFArmy where I provide #Dynasty, #Redraft, and #Analytics content for @DFF_Dynasty. Thank you so much! Make sure to be on the lookout for our other redraft advice pieces, posted here.
