With the 2023 NFL season wrapped up and the Super Bowl in the rearview mirror, it’s time to revisit the rookie class and conduct a redraft based on their performances. In this three-round rookie redraft series, we’ll analyze the impact, development, and surprises of the 2023 NFL Rookies in a 12-team Superflex format. You can check out Part 1 here, covering my first-round picks. Now, let’s take a look at picks 13-24!
Round 2
- Jaxon Smith Njigba (WR, Seattle Seahawks)
- FPPG: 8.81
- GP: 17
Despite a preseason injury, Smith Njigba played all 17 games, showcasing his resilience and talent. As the season progressed, he proved himself as a top receiver, affirming why he was a first-round draft pick.
- Will Levis (QB, Tennessee Titans)
- FPPG: 12.00
- GP: 9
Levis faced challenges after a draft-day slide, but he seized the opportunity as the Titans’ starting quarterback. With his arm talent and toughness, he has the potential to excel in the league.

- Tyjae Spears (RB, Tennessee Titans)
- FPPG: 8.26
- GP: 16
Working behind Derrick Henry, Spears showed promise with his performances. With Henry’s potential departure, Spears could take on a larger role in the Titans’ backfield.
- Dalton Kincaid (TE, Buffalo Bills)
- FPPG: 9.39
- GP: 16
Kincaid entered the league with high expectations and delivered some exciting plays in a dynamic Buffalo offense. With more consistency, he’s poised for fantasy success in the upcoming season.
- Bryce Young (QB, Carolina Panthers)
- FPPG: 10.81
- GP: 15
Despite a disappointing rookie year, Young has the talent to turn things around. Issues within the team environment may have contributed to his struggles, but there’s optimism for improvement.
- Josh Downs (WR, Indianapolis Colts)
- FPPG: 9.33
- GP: 16
Downs emerged as a dependable receiving option for the Colts, filling a crucial role in their offense. His chemistry with the quarterback bodes well for his future success.

- Michael Mayer (TE, Las Vegas Raiders)
- FPPG: 5.10
- GP: 14
Mayer faced challenges in his rookie season but showed glimpses of his potential. As the Raiders continue their search for stability at quarterback, Mayer remains a promising prospect in dynasty leagues.
- Zach Charbonnet (RB, Seattle Seahawks)
- FPPG: 6.54
- GP: 16
Charbonnet faced tough competition in Seattle’s backfield but demonstrated his abilities when given the opportunity. Despite a limited fantasy outlook for 2024, his long-term potential remains intriguing.
- Roschon Johnson (RB, Chicago Bears)
- FPPG: 6.81
- GP: 15
Johnson made the most of his opportunities in a crowded Bears backfield. With potential changes ahead, he could carve out a larger role in the team’s offense.

- Luke Musgrave (TE, Green Bay Packers)
- FPPG: 6.84
- GP: 11
Musgrave’s rookie season was cut short by injury, but he showcased promise when on the field. His rapport with the quarterback suggests bright prospects for the future.
- Tucker Kraft (TE, Green Bay Packers)
- FPPG: 4.62
- GP: 17
Forced into a starting role due to injuries, Kraft capitalized on his opportunities in the latter half of the season. With more experience, he could become a reliable target for the Packers.
- Chase Brown (RB, Cincinnati Bengals)
- FPPG: 4.29
- GP: 11
Brown’s late-round selection didn’t deter his performance, offering glimpses of fantasy potential in the latter half of the season. He’s one to watch for a breakout in 2024.
YO, thank you for reading my article! I appreciate your support and time. If you’re interested in more devy and dynasty content like this, come check me out! Follow me on Twitter/X @DFF_Woody. #DFFArmy #FantasyFootball #AlwaysBeBuilding #NFL #NFLDraft #NFLTransactions #NFLTrades #AlwaysBeScouting
