milroe

A “Way Too Early” 2025 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft: Part 3

We’ve made it to the third and final part of our 2025 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft series. In Part 3, I’ll give you my full second round of picks for Superflex TEP formats and some “honorable mentions” I believe could move their way up rookie draft boards over the next year. If you missed either of the first two articles, you can check out Part 1 here and Part 2 here. I cover my top 12 selections in these two articles and discuss player profiles and NFL projections. To summarize, here were my first 12 picks for this 2025 class:

1.01 – Carson Beck (QB – Georgia)

1.02 – Tetairoa McMillan (WR – Arizona)

1.03 – Luther Burden (WR – Missouri)

1.04 – Evan Stewart (WR – Oregon)

1.05 – Shedeur Sanders (QB – Colorado)

1.06 – Quinshon Judkins (RB- Ohio State)

1.07 – Emeka Egbuka (WR – Ohio State)

1.08 – TreVeyon Henderson (RB – Ohio State)

1.09 – Ashton Jeanty (RB – Boise State)

1.10 – Quinn Ewers (QB – Texas)

1.11 – Colston Loveland (TE – Michigan)

1.12 – Trevor Etienne (RB – Georgia)

We have 12 more picks to cover in this article, so let’s jump right in! (As a reminder, this is for Superflex, TEP formats.)

2.01 – Jalen Milroe (QB – Alabama)

Milroe finished sixth in the Heisman race last season as a redshirt sophomore, throwing for 23 touchdowns and rushing for 12. Critics say Milroe’s lack of pocket presence and ball security will prevent him from becoming an NFL starter. Still, a big 2024 season could put Milroe in the conversation of going top 10 overall. And his rushing upside makes him a compelling dynasty asset. 

2.02 – Ollie Gordon (RB – Oklahoma State)

Initially, I had Ollie as my RB6 of the class, but after talking with several devy analysts whom I trust, I’ve moved him up to my RB5. Gordon’s true sophomore season put the nation on notice, posting over 2,000 scrimmage yards and 22 touchdowns. Those numbers landed him a 7th place finish in the Heisman race and first among running backs. Gordon wasn’t overly efficient from a per-touch perspective, but this Cowboy offensive line didn’t do him any favors. He’s certainly proved he can handle a massive workload. 

2.03 – Isaiah Bond (WR – Texas)

Bond had a solid true sophomore campaign for Alabama, finishing with 668 receiving yards and four touchdowns. He’ll now be playing for the Longhorns, competing for targets alongside Matthew Golden (Houston transfer), Johntay Cook II, and Ryan Wingo. Texas should have one of the best WR rooms in the country, and I expect Bond to lead the pack. Bond has soft hands, is lightning quick, and can line up anywhere on the field and win routes. 

singleton

2.04 – Nick Singleton (RB – Penn State)

In 2022, Singleton posted one of the best freshman seasons in the country but appeared to have regressed in Year 2. All of his numbers, including yards per rush, missed tackle rate, yards after contact per attempt, and breakaway rate, were significantly worse in 2023. He’s been the primary rusher ahead of Kaytron Allen for his first two seasons but will need to return to his freshman-year efficiency to keep that role for the Nittany Lions. A year ago, we were talking about Singleton in the same breath as Quinshon Judkins, so I’m still holding out hope. I think he’s a talented back with the size, strength, and receiving ability to carry a three-down role. 

2.05 – Conner Weigman (QB – Texas A&M)

Weigman first showed us his abilities as a true freshman, earning the starting role over Haynes King, ultimately leading King to transfer to Georgia Tech. At 6’3″ and 215 lbs, Weigman has plenty of size and is an underrated athlete. Weigman’s arm strength is one of the best in the country, but he needs to work on going through his progressions and making the right decisions in the pocket. His sophomore season was cut short due to a foot injury, so we haven’t seen a ton from the young man yet. I expect a breakout junior season and believe he’s a future potential NFL starter. I’ve seen multiple mocks where Weigman goes late in the first round to the Jets. 

2.06 – Oscar Delp (TE – Georgia)

Oscar Delp is more of a projections-based bet since he played behind Brock Bowers for his first two seasons at Georgia. But coming out of high school, he was a 4-star recruit across all four recruiting platforms and the top tight end in the country for his class, according to 247 Sports. Though a limited sample size, we’ve seen flashes of brilliance from Delp when he’s seen the field as an underclassman. He has the size and athleticism to be a starting NFL tight end, and I think he’ll establish himself as the clear TE2 in this class after this 2024 season. 

omarion

2.07 – Omarion Hampton (RB – North Carolina)

Hampton was a bell cow for North Carolina as a true sophomore this past season and really excelled in the role. He finished with over 1,700 scrimmage yards and 16 touchdowns, establishing himself as one of the biggest offensive threats in the ACC. He plays with an aggressive downhill rushing style and is not afraid of contact. The one weak area of his prospect profile is the receiving game; his best season 12% target rate and 0.83 YPRR are not what you want to see in your typical PPR formats. 

2.08 – Tez Johnson (WR – Oregon)

Tez Johnson is an older prospect, entering his fifth collegiate season and second with the Oregon Ducks. He’ll be the starting slot receiver and should be the WR2 behind Evan Stewart. Incoming sophomore Jurrion Dickey will also see some looks, but Tez is the only one who plays primarily out of the slot. If you’d like a deeper dive into Johnson’s resume, you can check out my player profile article on him here. In short, this guy has been elite from a per-route perspective since he was a sophomore at Troy. He may be small (listed at 160 lbs.), but he knows how to score fantasy points. 

2.09 – Antwane Wells Jr. (WR – Ole Miss)

Antwane Wells is entering his fifth season after a left foot injury sidelined him for nearly his entire senior year. His teammate and fellow fifth-year senior, Tre Harris, will be back at Ole Miss as well, as is Jaxson Dart, so this Rebel passing offense should be a force to be reckoned with in 2024. I’d say it’s a coin flip in which wide receiver ends up with a better 2024 season between Wells and Harris, but I prefer Wells for dynasty projections. He’s the better route runner, can create separation more consistently, and has the physicality to compete at the NFL level. 

sanders

2.10 – Raheim Sanders (RB – South Carolina)

Many Devy players considered Raheim Sanders the RB1 of his class prior to the 2023 season. He was coming off an incredible sophomore season where he posted 1,443 rush yards, 271 receiving yards, and 12 total touchdowns. Unfortunately, Sanders’ junior year was riddled with injuries, which kept him off the field for much of the season and left him pretty ineffective in the games he did play in. Sanders has since left Arkansas and committed to South Carolina in hopes of rebuilding his NFL draft stock. He’s the largest back in this class and has the physical gifts to excel at the NFL level. I’m far from being “out” on Sanders; he still has an elite ceiling. 

2.11 – Tory Horton (WR – Colorado State)

Tory Horton is one of the more underrated wide receivers in the country, largely because he’s coming from a non-P5 school. This young man has been a massive college producer since transferring from Nevada to Colorado State in 2022. Last season, Horton finished with a target rate of 32.13%, leading the Rams’ receiving room by a hefty margin. He’s surpassed 1,100 yards and had eight receiving touchdowns in each of his last two seasons. All his peripherals were near the top of this class, including contested-target rate, contested-catch percentage, PFF Receiving Grade, and drop percentage. 

2.12 – Drew Allar (QB – Penn State)

I’ll be honest: every time I watched a Penn State game this past season, I was left thinking, “What exactly is Drew Allar good at?”. But after digging into his profile and situation, there’s plenty of reason to believe Allar is capable of being an NFL starter. Firstly, he threw just two interceptions to 25 passing touchdowns as a true sophomore in the Big Ten. Secondly, much of the blame for Penn State’s anemic 2023 offense can be placed on former OC Mike Yurcich. They have now hired Andy Kotelnicki (former Kansas OC), who should help revive this Nittany Lion offense. He turned the Jayhawk program around in his three seasons, coaching them to nine 40+ point games and five 50+ point games in that span. 

Allar is still extremely young and is continuously improving. At 6’5″ and 243 lbs, he’s maybe the biggest QB in this draft class. If Allar declares for the 2025 Draft, I think he’ll be a Day 2 pick and have an opportunity to start within his first few seasons in the league. 

Honorable Mentions

This exercise was incredibly difficult the further we got down the list, as there were several guys I wanted to place here in the second round. Here’s a list of the names I had in consideration:

Cam Ward (QB – Miami)

Donovan Smith (QB – Houston)

Jaxson Dart (QB – Ole Miss)

Devin Neal (RB – Kansas)

Nic Anderson (WR – Oklahoma)

Tre Harris (WR – Ole Miss)

Germie Bernard (WR – Alabama)

Deion Burks (WR – Oklahoma

Bryson Nesbit (TE – North Carolina)

Luke Lachey (TE – Iowa)

Thank you for taking the time to read this article, and I hope you got some valuable information you can use for your fantasy team! If you’d like additional insight into Dynasty Football news and analysis, please follow me on Twitter at @jim_DFF. Until next time, keep grinding out there, DFF family! #DFFArmy #AlwaysBeBuilding