Open the Control Room

Predicting and Analyzing the 2023 RB Carousel: NFC North

With NFL Free Agency underway, the stacked running back landscape is shifting more than it has in a long time. Over the past few weeks, I’ve gone over my predictions for the running back situations of each team, as well as the corresponding fantasy implications. Today, we’ll be taking a look at the changes that have already happened in NFC North, as well as what still is to come. Check out Part 5 of this series, where I predicted the AFC North. 

Detroit Lions

2022 Starter: Jamaal Williams + D’Andre Swift

Fantasy heartbreak strikes again for D’Andre Swift managers, as we’ve just received news that former Bears running back David Montgomery is on his way to his division rivals in Detroit. Montgomery is coming off of a fairly pedestrian year; his worst in his time as a Bear, despite playing in as many games as any of his other seasons in Chicago. However, this move confirms a lack of faith in Swift as a lead back, which has been a concern since entering the league in 2020. For more in-depth analysis, check out Chris Miles’ breakdown of the David Montgomery signing here.

When projecting both Lions’ backs for the 2023 season, this trade doesn’t move the needle for me a ton. Swift does certainly take a hit, as his ceiling continues to be capped by the presence of a more powerful runner taking high-value touches away. But, that presence was already baked into Swift’s valuation, so I’d recommend capitalizing on the frenzy right now and buying Swift at a discount. He will continue to be a solid RB2 on fantasy rosters with a high PPR floor and explosive big-play ability providing fantasy managers with the occasional big game. 

As for Montgomery, he inherits the Jamaal Williams role from last year- which wound up being a league-winner for a lot of fantasy players, as Williams had a huge year topping 1,000 yards and finishing as a near RB1 in fantasy thanks to his league-leading 17 rushing touchdowns on the year. I don’t expect Montgomery to match even half of this production, but something around that range is still likely worth rostering in most leagues. He will likely be a serviceable FLEX with fringe RB2 upside in 2023. 

Projected 2023 Starter: David Montgomery (confirmed) + D’Andre Swift

Chicago Bears

2022 Starter: David Montgomery

After letting Montgomery walk, the Bears are now in the market for a running back and have quickly turned themselves into one of the top fantasy landing spots for the 2023 rookie class. Many Bears fans were hoping to retain Montgomery, but an infusion of youth on a cheaper contract is the right move almost 100% of the time. 

Anyone who genuinely believes the Bears are rolling with Khalil Herbert as their lead back of the future is likely a Herbert manager lying to themselves. In a loaded rookie running back class, it’s almost a guarantee that the Bears throw a top-100 pick at one of the many talented players coming out. Herbert is a great sell right now if you can flip him for anything more than an early/mid-2023 third-round pick. He’ll be a solid backup and a rosterable backup, likely in a Michael Carter-Esque role ushering in the new star. Let’s talk about some rookies who could wind up being that Breece Hall.

This would be a wild, controversial landing spot for Bijan Robinson. I love that fit from an NFL perspective, but there are a couple of holes in it as well. Firstly, the Bears are not exactly in a position to be spending first-round draft capital on a running back; they simply have too many other holes on their roster to fill. But, if they can snag Bijan with an early second, I don’t hate the value there at all. Secondly, running backs alongside elite rushing QBs have historically been frustrating for fantasy purposes, as a lot of touchdowns are siphoned away from the bell cow, which puts a cap on their overall production. It’s not the ideal landing spot for 1.01 owners, but I promise you the Bears will be considering just how scary it would be for opposing defenses to have to contain both Fields and Robinson as threats coming out of the backfield. I love this as a football fan, but as a fantasy asset, it wouldn’t be ideal for Bijan.

Jahmyr Gibbs would be an explosive threat next to Fields that would genuinely be impossible to contain. Gibbs’ ceiling is sky high, and his torching quickness and agility might make the read-option with Fields even more of a headache to gameplan for than Bijan would. This is my favorite fit for the Bears, as I think they could land Gibbs with an early to mid 2nd round pick. Gibbs wouldn’t be a 3-down back most likely, but with Herbert being a pretty densely built back with decent power, the two could complement each other nicely and become a threatening change-of-pace duo.

Any rookie selected by Chicago in round 2 should be a target for fantasy managers in rookie drafts. They have a chance to be impact players in one of the most high-upside offenses in the league. I would project an elite prospect like Robinson or Gibbs to immediately contend for a top-12 finish in 2023, and only grow into their role as Fields and the Bears’ offense continues to progress. I’m all in on Chicago’s offense this year, and you should be too.  

Projected 2023 Starter: Jahmyr Gibbs + Khalil Herbert

Minnesota Vikings

2022 Starter: Dalvin Cook

Vikings star running back Dalvin Cook has had murmurs of a possible departure start to ramp up recently. While it’s tricky to predict if that will happen, I think it’s likely. Cook is currently on a gross, backloaded contract that he signed back in 2020. The Vikings could wait a year and cut him after 2023, which would save 11 million with just 6 million in dead cap, but I think a more likely outcome is a trade to a team with a flexible-enough cap situation to take on his contract. Thus, the pick that Minnesota will receive in return is likely going to be comically low, as we’ve seen other stars such as Amari Cooper and Jalen Ramsey get moved for metaphorical bags of chips to shake the restrictive contracts tied to them. I’d project Cook and a seventh to get moved for a fifth or sixth-rounder. He’s been linked to the Buffalo Bills, who could certainly be interested. I think the Bengals, Chiefs, Chargers, and Dolphins could all be interested in entering the cheap Dalvin Cook sweepstakes sometime soon. This would also move Cook out of the Vikings’ conference, which I’m sure they would prefer.

Minnesota thus becomes my official projected landing spot for Bijan Robinson. The 23rd pick feels almost perfect for Bijan, as we’ve had a couple of consecutive seasons with running backs going around this range (Rashaad Penny 27th overall, Josh Jacobs 24th overall, Clyde Edwards-Helaire 32nd overall, Najee & Etienne 24th & 25th overall, Breece Hall 36th overall). The mid-20s to early 30s is about as high as you see running backs go nowadays. Bijan is a better prospect than most of those listed but given the league’s concurrent shift away from valuing running backs, I doubt he goes in the top 20. Minnesota will find it hard to pass on Bijan at 23rd, and rightfully so. An offense starring Justin Jefferson, T.J. Hockenson, and Bijan Robinson gives Kirk Cousins a supporting cast featuring likely a top 10 player at each skill position- which is terrifying. 

Minnesota did have one of the worst defenses in the league in 2022, but they are filling some of those holes on defense in free agency currently, and doing that enough to make me feel decently confident sending Bijan their way. If this does wind up being the spot, fire Robinson up as the dynasty RB1 we have all been waiting on, the 1.01 in all formats, and a first-round pick in dynasty startups and redraft leagues.

Projected 2023 Starter: Bijan Robinson 

Green Bay Packers

2022 Starter: Aaron Jones + AJ Dillon 

Aaron Jones just signed a very team-friendly and fairly cheap extension to stay in Green Bay through the 2027 season. Jones retains his status as an RB2 for now and will continue to be a respectable player for the next few seasons. Jones will turn the corner in his 30s during the 2024 season and will begin to wrap up what has been a rock-solid career. A decline in production is imminent, and he will begin to fade out of fantasy relevance, but there’s nothing wrong with that. Hats off to Jones, who had some awesome years with Green Bay as a fantasy stud.

Jones’ backfield running mate AJ Dillon will also still be under contract in 2023. The two complement each other nicely and will continue to be effective on the ground for the Packers. Thanks to Jones’ receiving volume, he has a higher floor than Dillon, who is more of a touchdown-dependent risky FLEX play than a low-end RB2. Either way, both will more than likely have repeat performances in their 2022 campaigns, which means there is value to be had there in fantasy. I don’t expect league winners, but they’ll be solid once again.

Projected 2023 Starter: Aaron Jones + AJ Dillon

Thanks for reading! Be sure to check out the rest of this series where I’ve analyzed more teams’ running back rooms. Check out some other DFF articles to dominate your leagues and take a look at my Twitter @bwinknfl for more content like this!

Save to list