Open the Control Room

UDFA Unraveled: QBs

As the post-draft hype begins to fade and teams start looking for any asset on the waiver wire they believe can help bolster their roster, everyone is looking for that next edge. In a recent argument on @TaleofTwoRivals, we bantered quickly about the value of UDFAs in a dynasty league but reached no real conclusion. I began to think of who can be this year’s, Preston Williams. Who can take the mantle of Tony Romo, Arian Foster, and a few others and carry a team to the next level? Who can you buy low on? Who might be on the waiver wire? What follows is a case study of UDFAs who have finished in the top 24 of their position in a fantasy season, how their team responded to that success (were replaced via free agency, the draft, etc.) and what happened in the following year.

Using the free database constructed by @ff_spaceman, we are able to view the fantasy finishes of every player since 2003 and filter through by their draft positions. Worth noting, ff_spaceman does not factor Week 17 into his statistical construction, because, in his own words, “Week 17 scoring is for marks”. Once my head stopped spinning from the volume of data, I sat down to construct this narrative.

As we jump into QBs, ask yourself: how many UDFA QBs can you name? Are any of them less recent than the last three seasons? Don’t bother strapping in, this analysis will be quick. Since 2003, only two quarterbacks have posted a QB1 or QB2 season:

Tony Romo – The poster boy for UDFAs. Despite his hilarious botched field goal hold and regrettable tabloid romance with Jessica Simpson, Romo put together a solid career. In the 10 seasons that Romo was the Cowboys starter (2007-2015), and including the 2006 season where Romo became the starter over incumbent Drew Bledsoe, Romo posted six QB1 finishes and two additional seasons as a QB2. Romo is hands down the ceiling for UDFAs and speaks to their potential viability as the Cowboys continually chose to extend and pay him, with Romo deciding to walk away after a brutal back injury.

Brian Hoyer – A quintessential example of the NFL journeyman. Hoyer has done a lap around the NFL and is currently back for another stint with the Patriots. But in his travels, he has held the starting job for a few clubs and has never put together a comprehensive season except for his time in 2014 with the Browns. While his 2014 season was certainly nothing to write home about, he still managed a finish as a QB2. So what happened with Hoyer? His contract expired and the Browns had zero problems letting him walk. They had selected Johnny Manziel in the draft prior to the 2014 season (who flamed out in typical Browns fashion), and he was given the keys for the 2015 season.

While this seems like a small sample size because you only see two names listed above, that dear reader, is the point. In the last, almost two decades, only two quarterbacks have logged a QB2 or better or season out of the several dozens that have been rostered.

So what’s the take away here? Don’t bite. The dynasty community loves to get itself worked up over Twitter highlight videos and hyped narratives of small school quarterbacks like Kellen Moore, disjointed talent but physical specimens like Tyree Jackson, or chase intriguing landing spots like with Matt Moore. 

These players are undrafted for a reason. While we have seen that good talent can fall to the UDFA pool at other positions, it simply isn’t the case for quarterbacks. There is too much dependence, marketing, and franchise success locked up into who a team’s quarterback is for any team to leave a stone unturned and allow real talent to sink this low. Let someone else burn a roster spot or draft pick on these guys. Should another Tony Romo come along, pay up to get him once he’s good and save yourself the anguish of chasing a unicorn.

For more rantings, check out the rest of my articles at Dynasty Football Factory, and follow me on Twitter at @ff_walrus!

Save to list