Open the Control Room

2020 Dynasty MVPs

In this piece, I’m going to give you three potential candidates for the 2020 dynasty MVP. Of course, I could say that Christian McCaffrey, Michael Thomas, and Lamar Jackson will be the MVPs, but that’s not going to add any value to reading this article. I want to give some players, who aren’t in the top echelon, who have a chance to gain incredible dynasty value in 2020.

Each of these players could see the type of value spike that swings the power balance of dynasty leagues. By definition, the players in this article need to be young. Even if someone like Julio Jones or Travis Kelce has a monster season, they won’t be a dynasty MVP. They will not gain dynasty value since they’re already over the age cliff.

In 2019, Chris Godwin, Austin Ekeler, and Mark Andrews were dynasty MVPs. They gained extreme dynasty value and also produced as top options at their positions. I’m not necessarily saying that any or all of these players will make the jump. However, considering where each player’s value currently falls in dynasty leagues, they have the upside to demolish that value.

D.J. Chark

Let me paint a picture for you. The Jaguars are the worst team in the NFL, at least in my opinion. I believe they’ll lose at least 10 games, probably more. Their defense has been decimated from its place at the top of the league a few years ago and now projects as one of the worst units in the NFL. They’ve grown sick and tired of running back Leonard Fournette, and they have committed to sixth-round pick Gardner Minshew as their quarterback in 2020.

If the Jaguars consistently trail in 2020, that will force them to throw the ball heavily throughout the entire season. Chark had 73 receptions on 118 targets for 1,008 yards and eight touchdowns. He finished as the WR17 and averaged 15.1 PPG. Chark should further develop in Year 3 and has no serious challenge as the top target on the Jaguars.

Let’s say that Chark has a great season, but the Jaguars are horrible and have a top draft pick. Imagine what will happen to Chark’s dynasty value if the Jaguars replace Gardner Minshew with Trevor Lawrence or Justin Fields. Remember that Austin Ekeler had a lot of his fantasy stock rise in the offseason after he signed an extension, and the Chargers let Melvin Gordon go. 

A dynasty MVP is someone who improves in value from the beginning of this season to the beginning of the next, as dynasty is a year-round game. Chark has one of the best opportunities to make a meteoric rise given his situation. Chark also turns just 24 years old in September, so he’ll be plenty young enough to be a solid second-round dynasty pick if everything breaks right. Considering that he’s barely a fourth-round value right now, that type of jump would make Chark a dynasty MVP. 

Alexander Mattison

Like Chark, Mattison can have a meteoric rise in dynasty value over the 2020 cycle. Mattison has a previous roadmap for that type of value jump, as it happened in 2018 with James Conner. Conner was a second-year running back behind an incumbent workhorse back in a contract dispute. Mattison is in an identical situation, but if anything, Mattison is in a stronger position.

Unlike Conner, Mattison received significant playing time in his rookie year. Many might not know that Mattison had 100 carries in 2019, which he turned into 462 yards and a touchdown. Mattison averaged 4.6 YPC, a shade better than Dalvin Cook’s 4.5 YPC. Mattison also added 10 receptions on 12 targets for 82 yards, and he possesses a three-down skill set. Therefore, if Cook ever were unavailable for the Vikings, Mattison could step directly into his role. While I think Cook is a superior player, I believe Mattison could give 80-90% of what Cook brings to the table.

Cook currently holds first-round dynasty value, despite having an injury history and only one complete season of RB1 production. Even in his strong 2019 season, Cook still missed the final two weeks, including the Week 16 fantasy championship. Unfortunately for Mattison, he also missed those contests, allowing Mike Boone to step into the starting role. 

Everyone remembers Boone’s massive flop in Week 16, but many forget that Boone dominated in Week 17. Boone had 17 carries for 148 yards and a touchdown while splitting some work with Ameer Abdullah. If Mattison had been healthy, I have no doubt he would have played well, perhaps even better. Coming from everything the Vikings have said, there is no doubt that they see Mattison as the direct backup to Cook, even with Boone on the team.

Cook and the Vikings seem embroiled in a contract dispute that threatens to become ugly. Especially with the uncertainty surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, I would not be surprised if this drama extends further into the offseason and potentially even into the season. We already know that Mattison can play running back in the NFL from his 100 carries as a rookie. If he gets a shot at a workhorse role, he will succeed and demolish his current dynasty ADP. Therefore, Mattison is one of the best candidates to be the 2020 dynasty MVP.

Jonnu Smith

Each of the last two years, there has been a tight end breakout from a young player in Smith’s value range. In 2018, George Kittle broke out in his second season to finish as the TE3. Then, Mark Andrews did the same in 2019, jumping from a mediocre rookie season to the TE5.

While Smith isn’t a rookie, he’s right in the breakout age range for tight ends. Most tight ends don’t break out into fantasy relevance until they turn 25 years old, with Andrews in 2019 representing one of the most notable exceptions. Smith turns 25 in August, and he enters the 2020 season as the Titans’ clear starting tight end after long-time starter Delanie Walker’s departure.

Smith hasn’t done that much as a receiver thus far in his career. He saw few targets as a backup in 2017 and 2018, but he improved in 2019. Last year, he caught 35 of 44 targets for 439 yards and three touchdowns. Smith also added value as a rusher with four carries for 78 yards.

I love Smith in 2020 because the Titans have to pass the ball more than they did in 2019. As a team, they only attempted 448 passes, second-lowest in the NFL, ahead of only the Ravens. While Derrick Henry is a stud workhorse back, he cannot carry the ball on every play. The Titans paid Ryan Tannehill $62 million in guaranteed money, so they believe he can execute as a passer.

The Titans also have few options to compete with Smith for targets in their passing game. They have top receiver A.J. Brown, but no other significant pass-catchers. While receivers Corey Davis and Adam Humphries remain on the roster, I have no confidence in them. Therefore, I expect Smith to take over as the second target behind Brown.

If the Titans go to a more balanced approach and Smith gets a massive role, he has a limitless ceiling. I think Smith is one of the most athletic and talented receiving tight ends in the NFL, so if he got 80-90 targets, he’d be a fantasy monster. Tannehill and Smith displayed chemistry, and I believe that it can continue in 2020. 

Given Smith’s young age, he also has room to make a jump in dynasty value. He could quickly move from the double-digit rounds into the top 50 with a top-five tight end season. I think Smith is a great candidate for the 2020 dynasty MVP.

Thanks for reading this article. You can find me on Twitter at @DFF_Karp. I love to interact with anyone in the community, so reach out at any time! I take fantasy questions and help with all formats, so keep sending those questions my way.

Save to list